Tuesday 20 August 2019

White House hopeful Kamala Harris unveils Medicare For All health plan

The issue is becoming a key one in the Democratic primary contest that will determine Donald Trump’s opponent in the presidential election.

Democratic presidential candidate Senator Kamala Harris (Charlie Neibergall/AP)
Democratic presidential candidate Senator Kamala Harris (Charlie Neibergall/AP)

By Juana Summers, Associated Press

Presidential candidate Kamala Harris is filling in the details of how she would move 330 million Americans onto a single government health insurance system.

It is the fullest statement on an issue that is getting top billing in the Democratic presidential primary and one that has posed some problems for the California senator.

Ms Harris is a supporter of Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders’ Medicare For All legislation, but the plan that she released on Monday stops short of the full-scale overhaul that Mr Sanders has envisioned.

While Ms Harris would still replace the Affordable Care Act with a single-payer health plan for all Americans, she differs with Mr Sanders on some of the key details.

Ms Harris differs with the Vermont senator, a rival for the 2020 Democratic nomination, in slowing the transition to a single-payer system to 10 years instead of the four he has proposed.

She still envisions a role for the private system, just as long as it takes its lead from the government.

And Ms Harris is, for the first time, addressing how she would pay for a sweeping health care overhaul that Mr Sanders has estimated could cost as much as 40 trillion US dollars over one decade.

ipanews_789785ea-4764-4cb2-a9a5-8f3d02fa6571_embedded244366679
Bernie Sanders has proposed a Medicare For All scheme (Carlos Osorio/AP)

The debate over national health care policy has been one of the most animating features of the race for the Democratic presidential nomination.

And for Mr Harris, it has been one that has put on display the tension between her pragmatic inclinations and a desire to meet the demands of an energised progressive base seeking a liberal agenda to counter President Donald Trump.

In a Medium post published on Monday, she said her focus was on finding a way to lower health care costs.

“Right now, the American health care system is a patchwork of plans, providers and costs that have left people frustrated, powerless and insurance companies in charge,” Ms Harris said in the post.

“And the bottom line is that health care just costs too much.”

Ms Harris has repeatedly been forced to clarify her stance on Medicare for All.

During the first set of presidential debates she appeared to suggest that she supported abolishing private insurance, later clarifying that she does not.

And prior to releasing her own health care plan, she was criticised for saying that she opposes a middle-class tax hike to pay for Medicare For All without making clear how she would pay for it.

Ms Harris is releasing her plan days before Democrats meet in Detroit for the second set of presidential debates.

Though Ms Harris’ plan draws specific distinctions with Mr Sanders, the chief architect of the Medicare For All plan, they will not appear on the same debate stage.

But Mr Sanders’ campaign has already been critical of her new plan.

There's no way to pay for it (Medicare For All) Joe Biden

Mr Sanders’ campaign manager Faiz Shakir on Monday said that Ms Harris was “continuing her gradual backdown from Medicare For All” and suggested that she had been inconsistent on the issue of health care.

Ms Harris will appear on stage with former Vice President Joe Biden, the most high-profile candidate in the sprawling field to opposed Medicare For All in favour of a so-called “public option” that would allow people to decide between a government-financed plan or a private one.

Mr Biden, with whom Ms Harris memorably clashed during the first Democratic debates in Miami, has warned that a transition to a Medicare For All system could present coverage risks for Americans who defend on the Affordable Care Act.

Mr Biden also has seized on Ms Harris’ recent comments, in an interview with CNN, that she opposes a middle-class tax hike to pay for Medicare For All.

Mr Biden said Ms Harris was not being realistic about what it would take to pay for Medicare For All.

“You have a lot of people out there supporting that plan and are running and saying, ‘But I’m not for that tax’,” Mr Biden said recently in Las Vegas.

“There’s no way to pay for it.”

Mr Sanders has said as recently as this month that the sweeping overhaul of the US health system he envisions could cost up to 40 trillion US dollars over a decade, and he has said that one option for paying for it would be a 4% tax hike on families making more than 29,000 US dollars each year.

ipanews_789785ea-4764-4cb2-a9a5-8f3d02fa6571_embedded244287601
Joe Biden worked with Barack Obama to introduce the Affordable Care Act (Carlos Osorio/AP)

Ms Harris said that “hits the middle class too hard,” and she is calling for exempting households making less than 100,000 US dollars each year from that 4% tax, with “a higher income threshold for middle-class families living in high-cost areas”.

Mr Sanders estimated that the tax increase he proposed would raise 3.5 trillion US dollars over 10 years.

Ms Harris did not specify how much revenue would be raised in the scenario she’s proposing.

To pay for the difference, Ms Harris wants to tax stock trades at 0.2% of the value of the transaction, 0.1% for bonds and 0.002% for derivatives.

Ms Harris argues that by making the transition period from current policy to Medicare For All 10 years instead of four, the overall cost of Medicare for All will be lower than in Mr Sanders’ bill.

PA Media

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editors Choice

Also in World News