Saturday 19 October 2019

Whiff of Watergate returns

The parallels between Trump and Nixon are straight out of the dustbin of history, write Calvin Woodward and Nancy Benac

Donald Trump is feeling besieged by tormentors and hounded by Bob Woodward, just as Nixon was before him. Photo: AP
Donald Trump is feeling besieged by tormentors and hounded by Bob Woodward, just as Nixon was before him. Photo: AP

Calvin Woodward and Nancy Benac

The White House seethes with intrigue and backstabbing as aides hunt for the anonymous Deep (state) Throat among them. A president feels besieged by tormentors - Bob Woodward is driving him crazy - so he tends his version of an enemies list, wondering aloud if he should rid himself of his attorney general or the special prosecutor or both.

Now, does that sound like an echo from the early 1970s? For months, the Trump administration and its scandals have carried whiffs of Watergate and drawn comparisons to the characters and crimes of the Nixon era. But last week, history did not just repeat itself, it climbed out of the dustbin and returned in the flesh.

There was John Dean again, testifying on the Hill, warning anew about a cancer on the presidency.

Nearly every element in Trump's trouble has a Watergate parallel.

Special prosecutor Robert Mueller is leading an independent investigation sparked by a break-in at the Democratic National Committee, the same target that opened the Watergate can of worms - though this time the burglary was digital and linked to Moscow, not the Oval Office.

President Richard Nixon first ordered his attorney-general, and then the deputy, to fire the Watergate special prosecutor; they refused and instead quit, on a convulsive weekend that gave history the Saturday Night Massacre but did not derail the independent investigation or Nixon's collapse for long. Trump, for his part, fired the acting attorney-general as well as the FBI director James Comey, thus triggering the Mueller investigation that has dogged him for more than a year.

It is even some of the same reporters who are causing the president's pique.

It was Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, the reporters who uncovered the Watergate break-in, getting under the president's skin once again.

"Dem operative," Trump fumed about Woodward. "Degenerate fool," he said of Bernstein, who helped report a CNN Russia-probe related story that Trump contends is "a major lie".

"Everybody's trying to get me," Trump told an aide, according to the new Woodward book, Fear. The book describes a tragi-comedy inside the White House with top aides dismissing the president as an "idiot".

In Nixon's time, Henry Kissinger called his boss "meatball mind" behind his back. But in those days, the world did not have Twitter or a US president who would have been publicly airing his visceral feelings on it.

"This is a president who says things publicly that we know from the tapes that Nixon said privately," says Timothy Naftali, a New York University historian who directed the Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum. "It's as if Trump is wrestling with the history of Watergate openly. It's the president who is inviting these parallels."

Trump's list of those he considers enemies is obvious on his Twitter feed. It includes former political opponents, his own attorney-general, his predecessor and former national security officials, whose security clearances he's threatened.

Now he's added an anonymous senior official who authored a New York Times op-ed describing the president as amoral. The aide described a "steady state" within the administration working to temper Trump's erratic impulses - a portrait just a degree away from the "deep state" Trump says is resisting his policies. Trump said last Friday that he thinks the Justice Department should investigate the unnamed official's identity.

In Nixon's time, on August 16, 1971, a White House memo laid out thoughts about "how we can use the available federal machinery to screw our political enemies".

Prosecution, litigation and the withholding of grants and contracts were considered, and Nixon loyalists were asked to contribute names to the list.

Nixon's enemies list was written by John Dean, the lawyer-fixer who abandoned loyalty to Nixon and helped bring down his presidency. Democrats asked Dean to appear at the Senate's Supreme Court hearings as an expert of executive power. He presented himself as an older and wiser man.

"There is much to fear from an unchecked president who is inclined to abuse his powers," Dean told senators. "That is a fact I can attest to from personal experience."

As counsel to the president, Dean arranged hush money to be paid to the Watergate burglars who tried to find material helpful to Nixon's 1972 re-election at Democratic offices in the Watergate complex.

Dean participated in the cover-up of Nixon's culpability, before breaking with the president and delivering devastating testimony to the Senate Watergate committee.

He served four months in jail for obstruction of justice; Nixon resigned from office under threat of being removed by impeachment.

Dean's loose counterpart today is Michael Cohen, who as Trump's personal lawyer arranged hush money to women alleged to have had affairs with Trump.

Cohen pleaded guilty to eight criminal charges and said in federal court that he broke campaign finance laws as part of a cover-up that Trump had directed, an accusation Trump denies.

Or perhaps Dean's equivalent is Don McGahn, the White House counsel who has cooperated with investigators and sat for hours of interviews. It's not yet clear whether McGahn gave up material damaging to the president. Trump is not accused of any crime and the series of convictions Mueller has achieved against Trump campaign aides has not unearthed collusion between Moscow and the campaign. There's no smoking gun.

The parallels with Watergate only go so far, thus far, says Naftali.

Yet "Nixon's playbook for dirty tricks and abuse of power and political espionage is a useful source of questions for any investigation of an impulsive, erratic and potentially criminal presidency," he said.

"We'll be watching. The Nixon presidency makes us smarter as we try to make sure that our presidents don't do what Nixon did."

©Associated Press

Sunday Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editors Choice

Also in World News