Wednesday 26 June 2019

The adult in the room sternly reminds America to stand up to the threat to its democracy

Tweet: President Donald Trump. Photo: Getty Images
Tweet: President Donald Trump. Photo: Getty Images

Marc Fisher

He was, as ever, stolid, serious, sober. He spoke in clipped, cautious sentences. He said he was not saying a single thing beyond what he'd written in his report.

Yet when Robert Mueller finally spoke yesterday, breaking two years of silence, he delivered a nine-minute soliloquy that seemed as powerful an invitation to impeachment of the US president as anyone has delivered to date.

The special counsel who examined Russia's effort to interfere with the 2016 US election repeatedly said that this was the end - his final act in a position from which he is now resigning, his last words about President Donald Trump's possible role in obstructing his investigation, his ultimate conclusion that there would be no criminal charges against Trump.

But Mueller's statement, read with dampened expression, his eyes cast down at a script, sounded to many like a call to action - to Congress to consider his findings about Trump's behaviour and to the American people to pay closer attention to "multiple, systematic efforts to interfere in our election".

Intent on going out on his own terms, Mueller insisted repeatedly that his report was his final word. "The report is my testimony," he said, seeming to decline an invitation to testify to Congress. Yet he had clearly concluded that he needed to say something beyond what was in his 448 pages of written work. "I hope and expect this to be the only time that I will speak to you in this manner," Mueller said.

But from the halls of Congress to millions of screens across the country, Mueller's statement was received as anything but an ending.

In some quarters, there was a reflexive retreat to the battle stations of the past two years. Congressional Democrats heard Mueller punting the ball to them, for action on the obstruction charges that Mueller did not bring. The president, reacting by tweet, countered with a declaration: "There was insufficient evidence and therefore, in our Country, a person is innocent. The case is closed!"

But many Americans, listening to live special reports across all media, heard Mueller say that although "a president cannot be charged with a federal crime while he is in office", the Russians' efforts to interfere in the 2016 election "deserves the attention of every American".

Mueller (74) was the adult in the room, sternly reminding the nation to step aside from the partisan fray and focus on the threat to democracy. He delivered his message in the way he has conducted his career - by the book, in a code designed to inform rather than inflame.

Anyone expecting the special counsel to speak from the heart about what he really thought of Trump did not know who Mueller is. A decorated Marine, a career prosecutor who wears a white shirt to work every day, Mueller rose through the government and became FBI director and a valued adviser to presidents of both parties not by speaking his mind but by proving his reserve.

For two years, his silence flew in the face of a Washington political culture that feeds on jolts of Twitter adrenaline and cable cacophony.

Mueller sightings were infrequent and frustratingly uncontroversial: Here he was at the Apple store getting his device fixed. There he was at Reagan National Airport's infamously hectic Gate 35X, being totally calm.

There were sightings at church on Sunday, at his favourite restaurant in American University Park. For many months, the nation heard Mueller's voice only through the imagination of Robert De Niro's depiction of the special counsel as a humourless stiff on 'Saturday Night Live'.

Now, when he finally spoke, Mueller did so in a voice thinned by age, but strong in its controlled rectitude.

If Mueller's words seemed opaque, if he appeared to be more concerned about following Justice Department rules than about seeking to hold an alleged lawbreaker-in-chief to account, he nonetheless sent his message with a clarity heard at both ends of the polarised field that is Trump's America.

Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editors Choice

Also in World News