Friday 6 December 2019

Bill to declare Israel Jewish state sparks clash with US

Justice Minister Tzipi was in a row with Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu. REUTERS/Gil Cohen Magen
Justice Minister Tzipi was in a row with Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu. REUTERS/Gil Cohen Magen
Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. REUTERS/Baz Ratner

Robert Tait

A row has broken out between Israel and its closest ally, the United States, after a leading right-winger said Washington's criticism of a highly contentious bill to declare the country a Jewish state, while stripping Arabs of national rights, was not welcome.

The rebuff was delivered by Naftali Bennett, the economy minister and leader of the nationalist Jewish Home party, after the US State Department suggested the bill - approved by the cabinet on Sunday - undermined Israel's democratic credentials.

"Israel is a Jewish and democratic state and all its citizens should enjoy equal rights. We expect Israel to stick to its democratic principles," said Jeff Rathke, a US State Department spokesman. That drew a quick riposte from Mr Bennett, who told Israel Radio: "I say to the Americans: we will manage the matters of the state of Israel ourselves."

The exchange occurred as divisions over the proposed nation state law threatened to tear apart the rickety coalition led by Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel's prime minister, amid rising speculation about a possible early general election.

A scheduled vote on the bill in the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, was postponed from yesterday until next week, in an effort to find a compromise after two prominent centrists, Tzipi Livni, the justice minister, and Yair Lapid, the finance minister, said they would quit the government - effectively collapsing the coalition - if the bill passed in its current form.

The bill, approved in Sunday's divisive cabinet meeting, would define Israel as "the nation-state of the Jewish people", enshrine Jewish law as the basis of the legal system and relegate Arabic from its current status as an official language.

Opponents say it elevates Israel's Jewish character at the expense of its status as a democracy, set out in the country's 1948 declaration of independence. Ms Livni, the leader of the centrist Hatnua party - who had a heated exchange with Mr Netanayahu during the cabinet meeting - called the bill "jingoistic, divisive and (driven by) a group of extremists", at a conference in Sderot yesterday.

The liberal 'Haaretz' newspaper was equally scathing, warning that it would "remove the state of Israel from the community of democratic nations, and give it a place of honour instead beside those dark regimes in which minorities are persecuted".

Mr Netanyahu, who supported a more hard-line form of the bill approved by Ze'ev Elkin, a right-wing MP from his Likud party, said the change was necessary because of challenges - from Palestinians and others - to Israel's status as a Jewish state. But critics warn the bill encourages racism when tensions are already running high between Israel's Jews and its Arab minority.

Following widespread reports of a Jewish backlash after a recent spate of deadly Palestinian attacks, Rueven Rivlin, the president of Israel, withdrew an invitation to Amir Benayoun, a popular Jewish singer, to perform at a forthcoming anniversary event marking the expulsion of Jews from Arab countries in 1948, over a new song he wrote that expresses anti-Arab sentiments.(© Daily Telegraph, London)

Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editors Choice

Also in World News