Friday 20 September 2019

Vatican's treasurer to face trial on old sex abuse claims

Cardinal George Pell leaves Melbourne Magistrates’ Court yesterday. Photo: Michael Dodge/ Getty Images
Cardinal George Pell leaves Melbourne Magistrates’ Court yesterday. Photo: Michael Dodge/ Getty Images
Pope Francis addressing St Peter’s Square on Sunday

Jonathan Pearlman in Sydney

Cardinal George Mr Pell, the Vatican's treasurer, has become the most senior Catholic figure to face sexual assault charges after a court in Melbourne committed him to stand trial on historical offences involving multiple victims.

After being asked for a plea, 76-year-old Mr Pell, a trusted aide of Pope Francis, stated firmly and loudly: "Not guilty."

Magistrate Belinda Wallington dismissed about half the charges because of a lack of evidence or concerns about witness credibility. These included, according to Mr Pell's lawyer, the more "vile" of the alleged offences.

But Ms Wallington ordered the Cardinal to face trial by jury for alleged sexual offending in the 1970s at a pool in Ballarat, near Melbourne, and at St Patrick's Cathedral in Melbourne in the 1990s, when he was the city's Archbishop. After the magistrate left the court, a group of the Cardinal's critics broke into applause.

The precise details of the alleged offences are yet to be revealed. Much of the committal hearing was closed to the public because the case involved alleged sexual offences.

The case follows an explosive report aired on ABC News in 2016, in which two men claimed they were groped by Mr Pell in the late 1970s at Eureka pool in Ballarat, where the cleric had grown up and worked.

Pope Francis addressing St Peter’s Square on Sunday
Pope Francis addressing St Peter’s Square on Sunday

"He would play games like throw the kids out of the water," Lyndon Monument, a former student, claimed to the ABC. "You know, his hand touching your genitals and stuff on the outside of your bathers or shorts. And then that slowly became hand down the front of the pants or your bathers, or whatever you call them."

One of the men who made the allegations, Damian ­Dignan, died in January after a long illness.

Pope Francis did not force Mr Pell to resign after he was charged and granted leave to the Cardinal to return to Australia to fight the charges. But the decision to move the case to trial could place pressure on the Vatican for a stronger response, especially as Pope Francis has claimed he has "zero tolerance" for abuse in the church.

Mr Pell, who holds a doctorate from Oxford, has long been an imposing figure in Australia and has been heavily criticised for his handling of child sex abuse by Catholic priests. He is known for his staunchly ­conservative views on issues such as homosexuality and abortion, which he once said was a "worse moral scandal" than child sex abuse by priests.

As rumours swirled about his alleged misconduct, and alleged victims began to come forward in the media, Mr Pell insisted on his innocence and left his post in the Vatican to fight the charges after he was charged in June last year.

His lawyer, Robert Richter, told the court in his final submissions two weeks ago that the complainants might have been seeking to punish the Cardinal for failing to act against abuse by clerics.

Campaigners for sex abuse victims have been critical of Pope Francis, who hand-picked Mr Pell to oversee the Vatican's finances despite controversy in Australia over the Cardinal's handling of sex abuse. (© Daily Telegraph, London)

Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editors Choice

Also in World News