Friday 19 January 2018

Undercover halal slaughterhouse film reveals 'horrific' animal abuse

WARNING: This piece contains graphic images some viewers may find distressing

Dan Hyde

Disturbing footage showing "routine abuse" of sheep in a halal slaughterhouse has rekindled the debate over whether animals should be stunned before they are killed for meat.

Under halal law, animals are supposed to be killed quickly by single cut from a surgically-sharp knife.

Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
WARNING GRAPHIC CONTENT BEST QUALITY AVAILABLE Embargoed to 0001 Tuesday February 3 Undated handout photo issued by Animal Aid of a screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Issue date: Tuesday February 3, 2015. Four slaughtermen at Bowood Lamb abattoir in Thirsk, North Yorkshire, have had their operating licences suspended and an investigation is under way. Prosecutions may be considered in light of the alleged "horrifying yet routine abuse" captured on film by the animal rights group Animal Aid. See PA story ANIMALS Slaughter. Photo credit should read: Animal Aid/PA Wire NOTE TO EDITORS: This handout photo may only be used in for editorial reporting purposes for the contemporaneous illustration of events, things or the people in the image or facts mentioned in the caption. Reuse of the picture may require further permission from the copyright holder.
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire

Although 80 per cent of halal meat is stunned, the number of sheep killed without stunning is rising due to campaigning by Muslims, figures show.

Secret filming in an halal abattoir in Yorkshire showed "horrifying" treatment of animals killed without stunning.

Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire

Workers were shown hacking and sawing at the animals' throats with apparently blunt knives. In one instance the procedure, which according to Islamic law should be instantaneous, took five attempts.

Halal rules also state that animals should never see the knife or witness others being killed, protecting them against unnecessary trauma.

Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire

But the footage showed a man wearing a Muslim kufi skullcap at Bowood Lamb abattoir in Thirsk regularly sharpening knives in front of the sheep. Due to the design of the slaughterhouse, in which animals were forced on to conveyor belts, the sheep typically saw another member of the flock having its throat cut, bleeding on the floor and being hoisted and shackled.

In a direct contravention of animal UK animal welfare law, 431 of the 500 sheep observed were "shunted off" the conveyor within 20 seconds of being cut.

Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire
Screen grab taken from spy-cam footage of a halal slaughterhouse, where sheep have their throats cut without being stunned, which has led to action by the Food Standards Agency (FSA). Animal Aid/PA Wire

British law prohibits the slaughtering of animals unless they have been stunned, but there are exemptions for Jewish and Muslim producers.

Religious leaders from both communities have always insisted that halal and and kosher meat is produced in a humane way.

The film captured by lobby group Animal Aid, which has used subterfuge to place cameras in 10 abattoirs since 2009, showed evidence of repeated malpractice.

John Blackwell, president of the British Veterinary Association, said: "Slaughter without stunning unnecessarily compromises animal welfare at the time of death and as such we call for an end to its practice.

"The Animal Aid film is truly shocking. Whether in a stun or non-stun abattoir these abuses would warrant sanctions under the current welfare legislation."

The group has collected more than 100,000 signatures for a petition to have the issue of stunning animals debated in Parliament. It has gained the backing of celebrities including Ricky Gervais, actress Sadie Frost and Queen guitarist Brian May.

Awal Fuseini, of the Halal Food Authority, condemned the practices in the video as unrepresentative of halal slaughtering and against Islamic law.

"Any imam [Islamic leader] who looks at this video would be disturbed," he said.

"Every activity is a contravention of animal welfare standards – the operatives are poorly behaved and trained, the knives are not sterilised and do not appear sharp.

"These are very special circumstances and have nothing to do with stunning or non-stunning."

The number of sheep and goats killed without stunning rose 60 per cent to 2.4 million last year, according to the Food Standards Agency.

On receiving the video evidence, the regulator immediately suspended the licence of the slaughtermen involved and initiated an investigation.

"There is no excuse for treating animals in the way shown on the video and we are therefore investigating the footage with a view to prosecution," a spokesman said.

Kate Fowler, head of campaigns at Animal Aid, said the footage was among the "most extreme" examples of animal abuse in the 10 films captured. It was the first video showing meat killed in a religious manner.

Workers at Bowood stamped on sheep, kicked them in the head and shouted at them as they attempted to transport them to onto the conveyor belt. Ms Fowler said the poor design of the slaughterhouse made matters worse.

However, she said such treatment was unrelated to religious practice and called for CCTV to be placed in every abattoir.

Earlier films at slaughterhouses that did use stunning had shown animals being punched in the head, burnt with cigarettes, beaten with sticks, given electric shocks with stunning tongs, thrown and kicked.

A spokesman for Bowood abattoir was unavailable for comment.

Telegraph.co.uk

Promoted Links

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Promoted Links

Editors Choice

Also in World News