| 18.6°C Dublin

Merkel and Macron's EU pact

Chancellor backs deal for mutualised debt to help poorer nations


Meeting: Angela Merkel and Emmanuel Macron hold a joint video conference on Tuesday. Photo: Kay Nietfeld/Pool via Reuters/File Photo

Meeting: Angela Merkel and Emmanuel Macron hold a joint video conference on Tuesday. Photo: Kay Nietfeld/Pool via Reuters/File Photo

Meeting: Angela Merkel and Emmanuel Macron hold a joint video conference on Tuesday. Photo: Kay Nietfeld/Pool via Reuters/File Photo

It took a courtroom of scarlet-robed judges to spur Angela Merkel to make one of her boldest moves in 15 years as German chancellor: propose huge cash handouts to the European Union's weaker economies.

Ms Merkel was already worried about the future of the union after the coronavirus pandemic struck Europe in February.

But it was Germany's own Constitutional Court that tipped her hand, sources said. Its bombshell ruling on May 5 challenged the EU's reliance on European Central Bank money-printing to keep its weaker members' economies afloat - and the EU's governance.

Until then, Ms Merkel had opposed a proposal by French President Emmanuel Macron for a Recovery Fund that would, for the first time, bind all 27 member states to raise debt jointly.

"Initially they were on quite different positions," said one senior diplomat. "They reviewed the risk of a split in the EU. But then the Constitutional Court decision came and Merkel said: 'It's up to us, the governments.'"

A series of video calls between Ms Merkel and Mr Macron led to a plan for the European Commission to borrow €500bn as common debt and transfer it to the regions and industries hit hardest.

It would be a top-up to the EU's 2021-2027 budget, already close to €1trn.

Diplomats in Brussels, Paris and Berlin familiar with the discussions said Ms Merkel had dropped Germany's long-held opposition to mutualising debt to fund other member states when it became clear the EU itself was in peril.

The court ruling in effect put the onus on EU governments themselves to fund any fiscal response.

European leaders agree that, if they fail to rescue economies now in freefall, they risk something worse than the debt crisis 10 years ago - which exposed faultlines, fanned euroscepticism and almost blew up the eurozone.

The pandemic has derailed the recovery of the EU's most indebted countries. Italy's debt is shooting towards 170pc of national output, Greece is losing gains wrung from years of belt-tightening and, across the south, a collapse in tourism threatens millions of jobs.

Surely the moment for the union to live up to its name.

Daily Digest Newsletter

Get ahead of the day with the morning headlines at 7.30am and Fionnán Sheahan's exclusive take on the day's news every afternoon, with our free daily newsletter.

This field is required

But members' initial slowness to share medical equipment and readiness to close their borders seemed to demonstrate Brussels' irrelevance when national interests are at stake.

Divisions erupted at an all-night video conference of EU leaders on March 27 as fiscally conservative northern countries resisted pressure from a "Club Med" group to raise a splurge of mutual EU debt to tackle the effects of the pandemic.

Finance ministers agreed on April 9 to an EU-wide rescue plan worth half a trillion euro, but it was too little to fund long-term recovery and the feud festered on. Berlin insisted any recovery plan must consist of short-term, repayable loans.

Then Ms Merkel and Mr Macron began talking. "Merkel became increasingly aware that it was making Europe look really bad," said an EU official familiar with the two leaders' consultations with the commission.

Just when it seemed that this latest in a series of traumas, from sovereign debt crisis to a chaotic wave of migration to Brexit, could finally tear the bloc apart, the deal hints the two founder members can still provide the EU's steady core.

It may also boost Mr Macron's standing and his vision of more integration as Ms Merkel ends her long tenure.

The commission, which presents its own proposal on May 27, warmly welcomed the initiative but the deal is not yet done.

To pass, it needs backing from all 27 capitals, and Austria's leader Sebastian Kurz has already said he - along with the Netherlands, Denmark and Sweden - will offer only loans, not grants.

Most Watched