Wednesday 13 November 2019

Fury as men cleared of girl's rape because they were 'not violent'

The verdict has reignited a debate over the judiciary's treatment of women, which intensified with the 2016
The verdict has reignited a debate over the judiciary's treatment of women, which intensified with the 2016 "Wolf Pack" case, in which an 18-year-old woman was gang-raped during the running of the bulls festival in Pamplona. (stock photo)

Sophie Davies

Women's rights campaigners in Spain called for a change in the law after a court in Barcelona cleared five men of raping a 14-year-old girl and jailed them for the lesser charge of sexual abuse - ruling they did not use violence.

The men, who denied the charges, took turns to have sex with the teenager after a party in Manresa, a town to the north of Barcelona, in October 2016, the court heard.

They were sentenced yesterday to between 10 and 12 years in jail for sexual abuse, avoiding more serious charges of rape or sexual assault because the court said the girl was drunk and unconscious, did not fight back and the men were not violent.

Ada Colau, the mayor of Barcelona, took to social media to express her anger at the verdict, saying it was "outrageous" and the result of a patriarchal judicial system.

"I'm not a judge and I don't know how many years in prison they deserve, but what I do know is that this is not abuse, it is rape!" she tweeted.

The verdict has reignited a debate over the judiciary's treatment of women, which intensified with the 2016 "Wolf Pack" case, in which an 18-year-old woman was gang-raped during the running of the bulls festival in Pamplona.

The men, who included a former policeman and a former soldier, had shared videos of the incident in a WhatsApp group and then joked about it.

In June, Spain's Supreme Court ruled the five accused were guilty of rape and not the lesser crime of sexual abuse, increasing their sentence to 15 years rather than the nine they had been given for sexual abuse by a regional court.

Outrage and protests over the initial verdict prompted a government promise to change the law, but critics say the Manresa case shows how the penal code is still outdated.

"It makes no sense that the law continues to distinguish between abuse and sexual assault," said Nuria Gonzalez, a Barcelona-based human rights lawyer.

"Everything that happens after a woman says no, or says nothing at all, or happens through violence and intimidation, is against the victim's and is a sexual assault in which there is no room for mitigating or lower grades."

Spanish law requires that the plaintiff in a rape case must present evidence of intimidation or specific violence.

"Any attack on sexual liberty should be considered violence," said Graciela Atencio, a women's rights activist.

"It's important that they introduce the term rape into the penal code for all attacks that involve penetration and that any sexual behaviour without consent be considered sexual violence."

Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editors Choice

Also in World News