May’s voice problem during Commons speeches ‘a metaphor’ as PM loses vote
Some commentators bemoaned the Prime Minister’s ‘terrible luck’ while others described it as ‘humiliating’.
Theresa May lost not only the second “meaningful vote” on her Brexit deal on Tuesday evening, but also her voice.
The Prime Minister battled through discomfort to deliver increasingly croaky speeches before and after the vote, which she lost by 391 to 242, a margin of 149.
Labour MPs heckled her about not being able to make her speech before the vote, but the PM hoarsely quipped: “OK, you may say that, but you should hear Jean-Claude Juncker’s voice as a result of our conversation.”
Yet her voice was no better after the defeat was announced, as Mrs May appeared to suffer the same ailment which overshadowed her speech to the Conservative Party conference in 2017 as she stepped up to the despatch box.
Labour MP Rupa Huq compared Mrs May’s impaired speech to that of Doctor Who villain Davros, whose voice is electronically distorted.
“PM sounding like Davros, still threatening no deal,” she tweeted. “Catastrophic lack of leadership and massive humiliation.”
PM sounding like Davros, still threatening no deal.— Rupa Huq MP (@RupaHuq) March 12, 2019
Catastrophic lack of leadership and massive humiliation
Piers Morgan responded to the difficult night for Mrs May by calling for her to resign.
“She’s lost her vote, her authority, even her voice,” the TV presenter tweeted.
“Surely the only option left to her now is to resign?”
BREAKING: Another absolute drubbing for Theresa May. Her Brexit plan is obviously dead as a dodo. But how in good conscience can she carry on as Prime Minister? She’s lost her vote, her authority, even her voice. Surely the only option left to her now is to resign? pic.twitter.com/N65pIz33hU— Piers Morgan (@piersmorgan) March 12, 2019
And Labour’s Jo Swinson wrote: “PM’s voice is croaking – clearly a similar sore throat issue to that infamous conference speech.
“But it inevitably conjures up images of that set falling apart, in a metaphor for where the PM, govt and country are all at right now.”
PM's voice is croaking - clearly a similar sore throat issue to that infamous conference speech.— Jo Swinson (@joswinson) March 12, 2019
But it inevitably conjures up images of that set falling apart, in a metaphor for where the PM, govt and country are all at right now.
LBC presenter Ian Dale said he felt sorry for the Prime Minister.
“Theresa May’s voice has gone again,” he tweeted.
“You’ve got to feel sorry for her. Terrible luck.”
Oh no. Theresa May's voice has gone again. You've got to feel sorry for her. Terrible luck.— Iain Dale (@IainDale) March 12, 2019
However, journalist Stephen Pollard decried claims that Mrs May’s predicament made her “some kind of heroic martyr”.
“Her presence in Downing St has been an unmitigated disaster both for the country and her party,” he tweeted.
“Her croaky voice does not change any of that.”
Enough of this idea that May is some kind of heroic martyr.— Stephen Pollard (@stephenpollard) March 12, 2019
She has clung to office for no reason other than to cling to office. Her presence in Downing St has been an unmitigated disaster both for the country and her party.
Her croaky voice does not change any of that
Radio host Iain Lee appeared to find common ground with the Prime Minister, however.
“Theresa May doing her sick voice so she doesn’t have to turn up got work tomorrow,” he tweeted.
“Genius. We’ve all done it.”
Before the vote, her vocal struggles were mentioned by the SNP MP Stephen Gethins, who, while making an intervention, joked he would give Mrs May a “moment to get another cough sweet from the Chancellor”.
That was in reference to the speech in Manchester 18 months ago where, having been handed a fake P45 by prankster Simon Brodkin, she was unable to get through her remarks – eventually being handed a lozenge by Philip Hammond.
Letters also fell off the slogan on the backdrop as she made that conference speech.
Later in Tuesday’s debate, former Conservative minister and now Independent Group MP Anna Soubry paid tribute to the PM’s fortitude in continuing to persevere.
She said most people would take to their beds if unwell, but noted Mrs May “simply battles on”.