For the cartoonist whose portrait of Mohammed won a Texas contest, the police killing of two gunmen outside the meeting place was justice.
"They came to kill us and died for it. Justice," artist Bosch Fawstin tweeted yesterday.
Fawstin's winning entry depicts a sword-wielding prophet in a turban shouting, "You can't draw me." In reply, a cartoon bubble portrays the artist, his hand grasping a pencil, as saying, "That's why I draw you."
The American Freedom Defence Initiative (AFDI), sponsor of the Sunday night event, gave Fawstin, a former Muslim born in the Bronx, New York, $12,500 (€11,200) in prize money and introduced him to the crowd as a courageous and righteous man. The AFDI was co-founded by political activist Pamela Geller.
The Southern Poverty Law Centre, which includes AFDI on its annual list of US hate groups, plans to add Fawstin to its 2016 report, Heidi Beirich, director of the tracking group, said.
She said he would have been listed previously, but the centre did not know Fawstin's location. The organisation has since learned that his website is registered in New York City.
"He's like the artist of the movement," Beirich said. "His views, they are hate views."
For many Muslims, drawings of Mohammed are offensive. At the Texas event, Fawstin voiced another view. He said the issue was free speech.
"It's about us not being told what we can or can't do as Americans, as free people, as Westerners," he said in a website video from the event. "We are being told by an enemy that is at war with us that we can't draw their prophet."
"It is a sick, twisted thing and it has to be fought just by drawing," Fawstin said.
Fawstin invented the character "Pigman", the alter-ego of an ex-Muslim named Frank Warner, who ruthlessly puts down jihadists wherever he finds them, he told the conservative FrontPage Magazine website in 2011.
The son of Albanian Muslim immigrants, Fawstin has in interviews recalled drifting from the religion and developing an interest in drawing and comic books as a child.
He said he began drawing seriously in his late 20s after taking night art classes. The September 11 2001 attacks were for him a turning point, he said. But much about him remains a mystery, including whether Fawstin is his real name. In Sunday's webcast, his interviewer says Fawstin travelled from overseas. "From somewhere, and I'm here," he responds.