Monday 21 October 2019

Boy Scouts still deeply divided after vote ends century-old ban on gay members

Jennifer Tyrrell (L), who was removed from her position as a den leader in 2012 for being gay, hugs Pascal Tessier, 16, after a resolution passed to allow openly gay scouts in the Boy Scouts of America at the Boy Scouts' National Annual Meeting in Grapevine, Texas
Jennifer Tyrrell (L), who was removed from her position as a den leader in 2012 for being gay, hugs Pascal Tessier, 16, after a resolution passed to allow openly gay scouts in the Boy Scouts of America at the Boy Scouts' National Annual Meeting in Grapevine, Texas

Marice Richter

THE Boy Scouts of America have voted to lift a century-old ban on openly gay scouts in a major victory for gay rights activists.

More than 60pc of the group's National Council, comprised of some 1,400 delegates, voted in favour of ending the ban, effective on January 1, 2014, the group said in a statement. A prohibition on openly gay adult leaders remains in place.

The decision followed weeks of intense lobbying by gay rights activists and members of conservative organisations, many of them church groups that have traditionally formed the backbone of one of the nation's largest youth organisations.

"I'm a happy camper," said Mike Harrison, 71, a former chairman of California's Orange County Boy Scout Council who voted to end the ban at a meeting of the National Council in Grapevine, Texas.

"The process was a very civil debate... There wasn't any uncivilised behaviour. People stated their case, passionately and from many different angles," he said, adding that by yesterday it had become clear that "the younger generation of scouting just don't see it the way the old guard did."

The Boy Scouts' long-standing ban on gay scouts had become a polarising issue at the centre of the debate on gay rights in the United States, where gay soldiers may now serve openly in the military and where gay couples can wed in a number of states.

For months, the Boy Scouts have been caught between two sides in an emotionally charged debate that has seen both supporters and opponents of lifting the ban threaten to withdraw support.

The Boy Scouts has faced heavy pressure on one side from gay rights supporters and some of the major corporate sponsors who provide much of the group's annual funding, and on the other by a variety of major national church groups, who sponsor and support the large majority of troops nationwide.

"I just resigned from my troop," said Chris Collier, 41, a former troop leader in Alabama and Florida who said he would send his Eagle Scout award back to the organisation's national office.

"My grandfather earned his eagle award in 1938. I earned mine in 1990. I was hoping my son could earn his when he grew up. I'm sad, but this is their cross to bear. I'm no longer part of the organisation. I'll move in a different direction."

John Stemberger, an Orlando lawyer, Eagle Scout, former scoutmaster and founder of an organisation that opposes lifting the ban said the decision marked "a sad day for America".

He said he would be never again wear the Boy Scout uniform and would work to create a new scouting organisation "based on timeless values".

The vote came about three months after the organisation's leadership delayed a decision on changing its membership policy to research attitudes toward admitting gays.

About 70pc of the group's 100,000 Boy Scout units are chartered by faith-based organisations, according to Boy Scouts membership data. Some 22pc of the units nationwide are chartered by civic organisations, and 7pc are chartered by educational groups.

One of the major turning points in the debate came earlier this year when the Mormon church - the largest sponsor of scouting troops nationwide - expressed support for ending the ban. The Mormon church charters nearly 38,000 scout troops representing nearly a quarter million scouts.

The next largest faith-based sponsor is the United Methodist Church, which charters about 11,000 troops representing about 363,000 scouts. They, too, issued a statement supporting an end to the ban. The Catholic church, which sponsors about 8,400 troops, has taken no official position on the controversy.

While national polls show a growing acceptance of gay rights, an online survey of about 200,000 Boy Scouts members, parents and leaders indicated strong support for maintaining the ban, by a margin of almost 2-1.

But the Boy Scouts' top leadership endorsed the change and encouraged delegates to support it.

"Our vision is to serve every kid and give them a place where they grow up and feel protected," BSA President Wayne Perry told a news conference. "Our view is that kids are better off in scouting."

Acknowledging division within the organisation's ranks, top Boy Scouts officials said they believed those unhappy with the change would eventually return to the organisation.

"We will continue to work through these issues," said Tico Perez, the Boy Scouts' national commissioner. "In time people will decide that the best place for kids is in scouting."

Zach Wahls, an Eagle Scout raised by two lesbians, said the time had come for change.

"There is nothing Scout-like about exclusion of other people, and there is nothing Scout-like about putting your own religious beliefs before someone else's," Wahls, founder of Scouts for Equality, told a news conference.

Gay rights advocates gathered petitions with more than 1.8 million signatures in support of ending the ban while opponents collected about 250,000 signatures urging delegates to vote down the change.

Intel, one of the largest corporate sponsors of the Boy Scouts, said last September it would stop supporting troops that continue to ban gay scouts. Intel donated about $700,000 in 2009, according to the American Independent magazine.

That announcement followed pressure from gay groups that launched a nationwide campaign on urging Intel to withdraw its support. United Parcel Service Inc, another major sponsor, followed suit in November, as did Merck & Co , according to the gay rights group GLAAD.

Some of the nation's largest gay rights groups cheered the move to end the gay scout ban, and predicted the organization's ban on openly gay adult leaders would soon end as well.

"Today's vote is a significant victory for gay youth across the nation and a clear indication that the Boy Scouts' ban on gay adult leaders will also inevitably end," GLAAD spokesman Rich Ferraro said.

Online Editors

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editors Choice

Also in World News