Sunday 23 September 2018

A closer look at exactly how VAR works

There have been plenty of talking points during the World Cup already since the Video Assistant Referee was introduced.

Referee Deniz Aytekin consults the VAR system before awarding Italy a penalty at Wembley in a friendly (Nick Potts/PA)
Referee Deniz Aytekin consults the VAR system before awarding Italy a penalty at Wembley in a friendly (Nick Potts/PA)

By Press Association Sport staff

Russia 2018 is the first World Cup at which the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system has been used – and it has proved a considerable talking point.

That was the case once again on Monday night as England’s 2-1 victory over Tunisia saw a penalty given for Kyle Walker’s use of an arm as he marked Fakhreddine Ben Youssef but none awarded on two occasions that Harry Kane was manhandled in the area.

Here, Press Association Sport looks at the key issues regarding VAR:

What decisions can it be used for?

ipanews_d7067784-b587-4bd8-bc0a-af9e3fd9f02a_embedded237077451
Kyle Walker was punished for his tangle with Fakhreddine Ben Youssef (Tim Goode/PA)

The VAR system is designed to support the decision-making process in four game-changing situations: the awarding of goals and penalty kicks, the issuing of straight red cards and cases of mistaken identity. The referee on the pitch can request assistance with these decisions from, or it can be recommended by, a video officials team, who they are in radio communication with and are watching footage for “clear and obvious errors”. The on-field referee has the final say. They may have been talked through what the footage shows, or watched replays on a pitch-side monitor.

What does the VAR team consist of?

ipanews_d7067784-b587-4bd8-bc0a-af9e3fd9f02a_embedded237078264
Referee Wilmar Roldan did not award a spot-kick on either occasion that Harry Kane was manhandled (Adam Davy/PA)

At this World Cup, for each match there is a team located in a centralised video operation room in Moscow consisting of a VAR and three assistants. Thirteen referees have been selected to act solely as VARs during the tournament, while some of the on-field referees will also perform the role. The VAR team has access to 33 broadcast cameras, plus two offside cameras available only to them. For the knockout phase two additional ultra slow-motion cameras, one installed behind each goal, will also be available to the VAR team.

Can players, managers or others call for VAR to be used?

ipanews_d7067784-b587-4bd8-bc0a-af9e3fd9f02a_embedded237084111
Kane earned England a 2-1 win with a stoppage-time header, his second goal of the game (Adam Davy/PA)

Players risk a booking if they attempt to influence any official to use VAR and managers or other non-playing staff risk being sent to the stand if they do the same, or encroach on the area where the referee is reviewing footage.

When was it decided it would be used at this World Cup?

ipanews_d7067784-b587-4bd8-bc0a-af9e3fd9f02a_embedded236678904
VAR being used at the World Cup was rubber-stamped in March by the FIFA Council, headed by president Gianni Infantino (Nick Potts/PA)

The use of the system at this tournament was rubber-stamped by the FIFA Council on March 16, a formality after the International Football Association Board approved its use at a meeting earlier in the month. It had been trialled across the world since 2016, and Serie A and the Bundesliga were among the top-tier European leagues to have it in use last season. The Premier League did not, but it was trialled in some Carabao Cup and FA Cup matches.

How has it gone so far?

ipanews_d7067784-b587-4bd8-bc0a-af9e3fd9f02a_embedded237029045
France’s Antoine Griezmann scored a contentious penalty in the 2-1 win over Australia on Saturday (Darko Bandic/AP)

There have been concerns expressed about the system – not least in English football – prior to this tournament with regard to decisions made and how long reviews have taken, and after Monday’s England game, former Three Lions defender Gary Neville wrote on Twitter that it was “not fit for purpose” at the World Cup. There was a particularly notable incident on Saturday when France’s Antoine Griezmann scored a contentious penalty in a 2-1 win over Australia, a spot-kick awarded after footage of Joshua Ridson’s challenge on the forward was watched by the referee on the pitch-side monitor. Since then, penalties have also been awarded to Peru and Sweden following pitch-side reviews.

Press Association

Sport Newsletter

The best sport action straight to your inbox every morning.

Editor's Choice

Also in Sport