Stephanie Roche chooses the starting XI and formation Ireland should use against Scotland
Stephanie Roche believes Martin O'Neill should make tactical and personnel changes for Ireland's crucial Euro 2016 qualifier with Scotland in Jun.
Here is my starting 11 for the Scotland match (4-4-1-1)
GK. David Forde: Didn't agree with him being dropped. He's been good for us and while Given is obviously a legend and one of our greatest-ever players, he hasn't played consistently for the last four seasons. It just seemed like a strange move.
RB. Seamus Coleman: He's one of our best defenders and gives a lot going forward. First name on the teamsheet in my opinion.
LB. Robbie Brady: Made a mistake for the goal against Poland but works hard for the team and is good on the ball going forward. The last thing he needs is for his confidence to be totally sapped if he gets the hook against Scotland.
CB. John O'Shea: Solid at the back and worked well with Marc Wilson against Poland.
CB. Marc Wilson: While he can also do a bob at left-full, I think his best position is in the middle of the defence. I wouldn’t change any of the back line from Sunday.
CM. James McCarthy: Came in for some stick after his performance against Poland but he's a good all round midfielder and our best midfielder in my opinion. Players like him don’t do too much fancy stuff but fans need to appreciate his presence in the middle of the park.
CM. Glenn Whelan: Another who cops plenty of flak but he works hard and always puts in a shift when needed.
RM. James McClean: He done very well when he came on against Poland and was our most dangerous player. Such an honest player who is strong on the ball and gets crosses into the box.
LM. Aiden McGeady: Gets a rough time from fans a lot of the time but I think he brings a bit of flare that's needed. Needs more end product with deliveries into the box but gives defenders something to think about when running at them.
No.10: Wes Hoolahan: Very good on the ball. Finds little pockets to play in and is creative. I think he's needed in there.
CF. Shane Long: Tough decision not playing Keane as he's our top goalscorer and captain and with Long only having two competitive goals to his name I may be sticking my head on the line here. But I think we need legs up front and someone who can be a target. With Hoolahan feeding off Long and vice versa I think we could be dangerous. Keane would also be a great option to pull from the bench too as we all know about his goal scoring abilities.