Wednesday 18 September 2019

Des Berry: 'Joe Schmidt's World Cup plan had been compromised by issues outside of his control'

Ireland head coach Joe Schmidt. Photo: Matthew Childs/Action Images via Reuters
Ireland head coach Joe Schmidt. Photo: Matthew Childs/Action Images via Reuters

Des Berry

I was just listening to the radio this week when someone called out Joe Schmidt for not developing depth in the key out-half position.

There has been displeasure at how Ireland’s perceived lack of planning has led to uncertainty at such a late stage in the process.  

Last week, Ross Byrne was thrown into Twickenham for his first Ireland start, holding minimum experience against Italy and the USA from last November.  

This week, Jack Carty will make his full debut at the even more intimidating Principality Stadium, for his sixth cap. 

Since Ireland’s debacle against Argentina at the 2015 World Cup quarter-final, Schmidt has made it his mission to cover all bases from 1-to-23.

There isn’t a person on the planet that could accuse the coach of poor planning.

Ireland have played 42 internationals from the first post-World Cup match against Wales in February 2016 right up to last Saturday in London.  

Jonathan Sexton has started 26; Paddy Jackson nine, Joey Carbery six and Carty is about to join Byrne on one.

International Rugby Newsletter

Rugby insights and commentary from our renowned journalists like Neil Francis, Will Slattery, Alan Quinlan & Cian Tracey.

In 2016, Jonathan Sexton started all five of the Six Nations matches with Ian Madigan coming in for impact for all but the final round against Italy.

That summer, Paddy Jackson took over the controls to play out all three 80 minutes in the 2-1 series loss in South Africa.

At that point, Schmidt had invested an entire tour in the Ulsterman and seemed to have a clear pecking order, Sexton, with Jackson and Madigan locked in a battle to be the back-up.    

Madigan was not willing to continue sitting behind Sexton at Leinster and cut the umbilical-cord to Ireland by moving to Bordeaux-Begles that summer.

Schmidt recalibrated in pragmatic manner, twice starting Sexton against New Zealand in November 2016 and Jackson twice against Canada and Australia.

1773322 (2).png
Joey Carbery. Photo: Sportsfile
In behind, Joey Carbery was trusted with closing out Ireland’s first ever win over New Zealand in Chicago as well as two other contributions behind Jackson against Canada and Australia.

At the turn of 2017, Jackson was given the responsibility of leading the Irish against Italy and Scotland, Sexton taking over for The Big Three’ – France, Wales, and England.       

When Ireland resurfaced for the summer series, Carbery was awarded a first start against the United States before Jackson took over for the two tests in Japan, both men completing 80 minutes on all three occasions.      

It was at this halfway point that Jackson’s involvement in an infamous trial made it unwise to continue down that path, one year away from the cancellation of his contract. 

Schmidt’s plan had been compromised by issues outside of his control.

That November, Schmidt was backed into a corner, looking to promote and progress the next two in line.

He nailed his colours to the mast in increasing Carbery’s game time to a start against Fiji and four cameos off the bench in the 2018 Six Nations and the first test in Australia that June.     

However, Leinster were inclined to see Carbery as a full-back rather than an out-half, where Ross Byrne was beginning to assert his authority.

54byrne.jpg
Ireland's Ross Byrne. Photo: Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile
The Athy man’s ambition to play long-term at ten, with a nudge from Schmidt, caused a transfer to Munster.

Last November, Carbery and Sexton alternated as Ireland’s playmakers with two starts each, Byrne eased into the environment with minutes against Italy and the US.

Then, Carbery was struck down by injury and Jack Carty – the Connacht man only began to impress last year - was given three chances to learn on the job in the Six Nations against Italy, France and Wales.  

All of this led to the natural ranking of Sexton, Carbery, Carty and Byrne entering into this pre-season.

Through this cycle, Schmidt has had to cope with losing his second and third choice out-halfs in Jackson and Madigan.

This has led to accelerated learning for Carbery, who, like Sexton, has been frustrated by injury in recent weeks.

Effectively, for one reason or another, Ireland could be down to their fifth and sixth out-halfs, in limited time with limited opportunities.

The question has been asked: how can Schmidt not know his third choice out-half on the eve of the World Cup?

The question should be: how has he managed to prepare them well enough to take their chance?

56carty.jpg
Ireland's Jack Carty. Photo: Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile

JOE SCHMIDT’S OUT-HALF CONUNDRUM

2015/2016

SIX NATIONS

Ireland v Wales: Jonathan Sexton; Ian Madigan.

France v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Ian Madigan.

England v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Ian Madigan.

Ireland v Italy: Jonathan Sexton; Ian Madigan.

Ireland v Scotland: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

SUMMER SERIES

South Africa v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

South Africa v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

South Africa v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

2016/2017

NOVEMBER

Ireland v New Zealand: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Canada: Paddy Jackson; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v New Zealand: Jonathan Sexton; Paddy Jackson.  

Ireland v Australia: Paddy Jackson; Joey Carbery.

SIX NATIONS

Scotland v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

Italy v Ireland: Paddy Jackson; Ian Keatley.

Ireland v France: Jonathan Sexton; Paddy Jackson.

Wales v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Paddy Jackson.

Ireland v England: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

SUMMER SERIES.

United States v Ireland: Joey Carbery.

Japan v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

Japan v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

2017/2018

NOVEMBER

Ireland v South Africa: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Fiji: Joey Carbery; Ian Keatley.

Ireland v Argentina: Jonathan Sexton; Ian Keatley. 

SIX NATIONS

France v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

Ireland v Italy: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Wales: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

 Ireland v Scotland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

 England v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

SUMMER SERIES

Australia v Ireland: Joey Carbery; Jonathan Sexton.

Australia v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Australia v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

2018/2019

NOVEMBER

Ireland v Italy: Joey Carbery; Ross Byrne.

Ireland v Argentina: Jonathan Sexton: Joey Carbery.

Ireland v New Zealand: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Australia: Joey Carbery; Ross Byrne.

SIX NATIONS

Ireland v England: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

Scotland v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Italy v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Jack Carty.

Ireland v France; Jonathan Sexton; Jack Carty.

Wales v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Jack Carty.

2019/2020

WORLD CUP WARM-UPS

Ireland v Italy: Joey Carbery; Jack Carty.

England v Ireland: Ross Byrne; Jack Carty.

Ireland v New Zealand: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Canada: Paddy Jackson; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v New Zealand: Jonathan Sexton; Paddy Jackson.  

Ireland v Australia: Paddy Jackson; Joey Carbery.

SIX NATIONS

Scotland v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

Italy v Ireland: Paddy Jackson; Ian Keatley.

Ireland v France: Jonathan Sexton; Paddy Jackson.

Wales v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Paddy Jackson.

Ireland v England: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

SUMMER SERIES

United States v Ireland: Joey Carbery.

Japan v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

Japan v Ireland: Paddy Jackson – 80 mins.

2017/2018

NOVEMBER

Ireland v South Africa: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Fiji: Joey Carbery; Ian Keatley.

Ireland v Argentina: Jonathan Sexton; Ian Keatley. 

SIX NATIONS

France v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

Ireland v Italy: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Wales: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Scotland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

England v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

SUMMER SERIES

Australia v Ireland: Joey Carbery; Jonathan Sexton.

Australia v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Australia v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

2018/2019

NOVEMBER

Ireland v Italy: Joey Carbery; Ross Byrne.

Ireland v Argentina: Jonathan Sexton: Joey Carbery.

Ireland v New Zealand: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Ireland v Australia: Joey Carbery; Ross Byrne.

SIX NATIONS

Ireland v England: Jonathan Sexton – 80 mins.

Scotland v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Joey Carbery.

Italy v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Jack Carty.

Ireland v France; Jonathan Sexton; Jack Carty.

Wales v Ireland: Jonathan Sexton; Jack Carty.

2019/2020

WORLD CUP WARM-UPS

Ireland v Italy: Joey Carbery; Jack Carty.

England v Ireland: Ross Byrne; Jack Carty.

Online Editors

The Left Wing: Ireland's fullback dilemma, World Cup bonding and the squad standby list

Also in Sport