Sport Rugby

Saturday 16 December 2017

O'Connell envious of England's Kiwi Tests

Captain feels Ireland should have been facing 'big three' opposition ahead of world Cup

Jonathan Sexton goes over for Ireland's second try against Argentina despite a tackle from Manuel Montero. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Jonathan Sexton goes over for Ireland's second try against Argentina despite a tackle from Manuel Montero. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Ireland's Andrew Trimble is tackled by Argentinian Jerónimo De la Fuente during last night's Test at the Estadio Centenario, Chaco. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Ireland winger Simon Zebo is tackled by Rodrigo Baez of Argentina. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Ireland centre Darren Cave is tackled by Argentinian opponents Rodrigo Baez and Gabriel Ascarate. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Jack McGrath breaks through a tackled by Gabriel Ascarate of Argentina during the first Test of Ireland's summer tour 2014. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Jonathan Sexton is tackled by Tomás De la Vega of Argentina during the first Test of Ireland's summer tour. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Ireland's Conor Murray is tackled by Argentinian pair Tomás De la Vega and Manuel Montero. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Andrew Trimble tries to get past Argentina's Jerónimo De la Fuente as Ireland go on the attack. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Paul O'Connell takes possession for Ireland from a lineout. Photo: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE
Ruaidhri O'Connor

Ruaidhri O'Connor

Ireland arrived in Resistencia not knowing what to expect and returned to Buenos Aires last night not sure what to make of it all.

Argentina 17 Ireland 29

A first Test win in Argentina came with caveats and not just because the opposition provided in the northern city were more of a Pumas development squad, who caused Joe Schmidt's side more problems than even the local aficionados expected.

There was much to admire about the way the Six Nations champions went about their task, but there was also plenty to work on.

With some of the season's stalwarts rested and others injured, there were opportunities available to make a mark and though Jack McGrath grasped the chance with both hands, Luke Marshall added more doubt to his credentials after a defensively shaky day at the office.

Ireland's line-out was good and their scrum better, while, when they attacked off both, they looked dangerous. However, they weren't able to sustain it through the phases.


Their defence let them down against an unheralded, but dangerous Argentinian team, who possessed some real fizz behind the scrum.

There were impressive debuts for Robbie Diack and Kieran Marmion, stand-out moments from Simon Zebo and Johnny Sexton was excellent, but it all happened so far off the beaten track that it was difficult to discern whether it had been a good, bad or indifferent day at the office.

Schmidt appears to feel that Ireland would have been better off – like Wales, England and France – facing one of the big three 14 months out from the World Cup and this was also voiced by captain Paul O'Connell, who certainly seemed a bit jealous of Chris Robshaw and his side having three cracks at the All Blacks to test themselves after their Six Nations exploits.

"You would love to have what England have in New Zealand. they followed the Six Nations up with a really big performance down there," O'Connell lamented.

"We didn't do that, but at the same time, it was a really tough game. For a few of the young guys and a few of the guys who got their first cap, it is good to come down to a place like this and get a real tough test and come through it.

"I think the result was good, the performance was disappointing. I think we started quite well and I suppose let them back into the game. It was a real slog throughout, a real tough physical game."

It didn't look like being that tough at the start when Ireland started like a train, holding on to the ball and finding plenty of gaps in the home defence.

They should have been ahead by far more than 6-3 by the time Argentina struck for a stunning first try when down to 14 men after No 8 Benjamin Macome took Andrew Trimble out in the air on the half-hour mark.

Defence coach Les Kiss will be neither happy with the concession of this try nor the missed first-up tackles that plagued the performance, while Schmidt will also be demanding improvement from his players when in possession.

Darren Cave and Marshall made stunning line breaks, only to find no support on their shoulders; the otherwise excellent Diack ignored an overlap and Conor Murray went close, and thought he'd scored, only for the referee to think otherwise.

Instead, they had to make do with two Sexton penalties, while Nicolas Sanchez drew one back for Argentina before beating Marshall all ends up and feeding Manuel Montero, who handed Sexton off to score.

It lifted the locals, but Ireland responded like the champions they are. Zebo caught Sexton's restart brilliantly before the Pumas pulled him back into a ruck at the next phase. O'Connell pointed to the corner, caught the line-out and the maul marched over, with Chris Henry touching down.

Sexton missed the conversion as Ireland led 11-10 at the break, but he capitalised on a brilliant Diack line-out steal to score the all-important second try two minutes after the interval following some excellent work from Marshall.

Still Argentina came, but Sanchez got overly ambitious and Trimble read his mind, picking off his pass to run in the intercept from halfway and putting the contest beyond doubt.

Ian Madigan, on for the injured Sexton, closed it out, while debutant Marmion went close to a fourth try and Cave put a foot in touch finishing off an outrageous piece of Zebo skill, before Tomás de la Vega pulled back a try in the closing stages for the hosts.

For Schmidt, there is work to be done in the review room as he assesses a mixed display on his side's first post-Six Nations outing.

"I'll look more forensically at the video and we'll be able to see a little bit more of the individual efforts," he said.

"You get a little bit encompassed by the team delivery during the match, then you try and divide that into seeing what the individual delivery was like.

"There were a few guys who, at first glance, appeared to do a good job and other guys who did bits and pieces well, but will have things to work on.

"I'm always hoping there's a lot of room for improvement and I think this Argentinian side can get better as well."

Ireland returned to Buenos Aires yesterday for a break before moving tomorrow to Tucuman, where they'll expect more in the second Test, both from themselves and their opponents.

However, with the Leinster starters ready to return to bolster the ranks and another week in camp there is far more Schmidt can get out of his squad, who should be more cohesive and, as a result, more comfortable in the north-west.

Argentina: J Tuculet (S Cordero 73); S Cordero (LG Amorosino 65), J De La Fuente, G Ascarate, N Montero; N Sanchez (SG Iglesias 70), M Landajo (capt) (T Cubelli 64); LN Paz (B Postiglioni 76), M Cortese (J Montoya 58), R Herrera (NT Chaparro 56); M Carizza (M Alemanno h-t), T Lavanini; R Baez (JO Desio 63), T De la Vega, B Macome.

Ireland: F Jones; A Trimble, D Cave, L Marshall (F McFadden 56), S Zebo; J Sexton (I Madigan 64), C Murray (K Marmion 58); J McGrath (D Kilcoyne 60), R Best (D Varley 67), M Ross (R Ah You 67); I Henderson, P O'Connell (capt) (D Toner 68); R Diack, C Henry, J Murphy (J Heaslip 58).

Referee: G Jackson (New Zealand).

Indo Sport

Promoted Links

Sport Newsletter

The best sport action straight to your inbox every morning.

Promoted Links

Editor's Choice

Also in Sport