Wednesday 18 September 2019

Dermot Crowe: 'Micheal Donoghue's departure has thrown Galway back into a period of uncertainty and instability'

Micheál Donoghue. Photo: Sportsfile
Micheál Donoghue. Photo: Sportsfile

Dermot Crowe

There are management reigns that are characterised by high jinks and melodrama, outbursts and moments of controversy - Micheal Donoghue's wasn't one of those. He was hurling management's Quiet Man.

His surprise departure after four years leaves a hole that will be hard to fill and throws Galway back into a period of uncertainty and instability - which has bedevilled them in the past.

Please log in or register with for free access to this article.

Log In

Donoghue took over after the management of Anthony Cunningham unraveled - and not in a tidy manner - with players revolting and Cunningham, for a while at least, digging in his heels. The cumulative effect of Galway's frustrations at not having won an All-Ireland in, by then, almost 30 years was proving an unbearable stress for all associated with the effort to remedy that failure.

Galway had become a study in under-achievement, with repeated success at minor and under-21 unable to provide the impetus needed for a senior breakthrough. The arrival of a genius player like Joe Canning, rather than liberating Galway, seemed merely to make the journey more taxing and perplexing.

When the breakthrough remained elusive, and Canning began to move in his late 20s, there was a growing preoccupation about whether or not he would go through his career without winning a Celtic Cross.

Numerous managers have come and gone since Cyril Farrell led Galway to the Promised Land in 1988. Galway were infuriatingly unpredictable; capable of defeating Kilkenny, when a serious force, in All-Ireland semi finals in 2001 and '05, and bamboozling them in the Leinster final in 2012, only to later trip up, get cold feet, unable to complete the job. In matrimonial terms, Galway would make an excellent marriage proposal and gain the bride-to-be's consent - only to then not turn up at the altar.

And the clock kept ticking: Canning getting closer to 30; Galway getting closer to 30 years without an All-Ireland.

3 September 2017; Galway's Joe Canning watches on as captain David Burke lifts the Liam MacCarthy cup following the GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Final match between Galway and Waterford at Croke Park in Dublin. Photo by Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile

Donoghue's appointment was announced in December, 2015, a year in which Galway had reached the All-Ireland final against Kilkenny with high hopes, played well in the first half and proved desperately disappointing in the second.

GAA Newsletter

Expert GAA analysis straight to your inbox.

When the players revolted against Cunningham, there was a constituency of opinion that felt the players needed to take on more responsibility for those shortcomings and stop deflecting blame on to managements. It was clear there was a breakdown in the relationship between players and management but Donoghue would be inheriting a group that, in the public eye, needed to go out and redeem themselves. If they did not show some progress on the field they would not expect much public sympathy.

He was, therefore, undertaking a role that would bring significant pressure and could be deemed a huge gamble. In his first season they were relegated from Division 1A, losing a play-off to Cork, and then overpowered by Kilkenny in the Leinster final. The year ended with a one-point defeat by Tipp, the eventual winners, in the All-Ireland semi-finals.

After the loss to Kilkenny in the Leinster final he was pilloried as "an amiable curate" for his sideline manner - the manner being considered too stoic and gentlemanly. Why a manager going volcanic on the sideline should be seen as beneficial is hard to figure, except maybe that the person who penned those words was Ger Loughnane.

Maybe the sideline is a territorial battle but surely players in this day and age aren't relying on their manager going berserk on the sideline to gain advantage? Perhaps Loughnane's argument is that if Donoghue behaves like that on match-day he is unlikely to be hugely fired-up on the training ground and players need that presence. But that was his way and his way would ultimately prevail.

Donoghue stayed as he was, remaining unapologetically his own man, and focused on putting all the preparations in place as best he could he could. In the next year they swept the boards: League champions, Leinster champions, All-Ireland champions. The West was awake and the Quiet Man who helped mastermind it didn't need to shout from the rooftops like or crow like a cock at dawn. The results spoke for themselves.

He was unlucky this year. The Canning injury made the difference between being still in the championship and being eliminated and the injury to Conor Whelan against Dublin was also deeply unfortunate. The surprise in his leaving now is that, having watched what followed, he must have felt there was every chance that Galway could roar back next year and be a serious challenger. But four years is a long stretch for most mortals. And that one All-Ireland will safeguard his legacy.

Donoghue - the highs and lows


3 September, 2017

Undisputed peak of Donoghue's reign as Galway win the county's first All-Ireland senior title in 29 years, defeating Waterford 0-26 to 2-17.

22 April, 2017

A real statement of intent as Galway wipe the floor with Tipp, the reigning All-Ireland champions, in the league final, winning 3-21 to 0-14.

8 July, 2018

Galway retain the Leinster title with an emphatic win over Kilkenny in a replayed final, winning 1-28 to 3-15, having led 1-9 to 0-1 after 19 minutes.


19 August, 2018

Galway lose their All-Ireland title, beaten by Limerick on the last day, despite a spirited comeback. A relieved Limerick win 3-16 to 2-18.

14 August, 2016

Galway lose the All-Ireland semi final to Tipp by one point, having been beaten in the Leinster final earlier in the summer by Kilkenny.

15 June, 2019

Joe Canning's second half appearance after injury isn't enough to save Galway from a shock defeat at Parnell Park in the final round of Leinster group matches. Dublin's 3-19 to 0-24 win means Galway exit the championship on score difference following an unfavourable result in Wexford Park where the hosts draw with Kilkenny.

Online Editors

The Throw-In: 'Jim Gavin has achieved what Mick O'Dwyer and Brian Cody couldn't do'

In association with Bord Gáis Energy

Also in Sport