Wednesday 20 June 2018

Sweden SWE 1

South Korea KOR 0

REPORT

Belgium BEL 3

Panama PAN 0

REPORT

Tunisia TUN 1

England ENG 2

REPORT

Colombia COL 1

Japan JPN 2

REPORT

Poland POL 1

Senegal SEN 2

REPORT

Russia RUS 3

Egypt EGY 1

REPORT

Portugal POR 1

Morocco MAR 0

REPORT

Uruguay URY 1

Saudi Arabia SAU 0

REPORT

Iran IRN 0

Spain ESP 0

Ongoing

Denmark DNK

Australia AUS

France FRA

Peru PER

Argentina ARG

Croatia CRO

Brazil BRA

Costa Rica CRI

Nigeria NGA

Iceland ISL

Serbia SRB

Switzerland SUI

Belgium BEL

Tunisia TUN

South Korea KOR

Mexico MEX

Germany GER

Sweden SWE

England ENG

Panama PAN

Japan JPN

Senegal SEN

Poland POL

Colombia COL

Saudi Arabia SAU

Egypt EGY

Uruguay URY

Russia RUS

Spain ESP

Morocco MAR

Iran IRN

Portugal POR

Denmark DNK

France FRA

Australia AUS

Peru PER

Iceland ISL

Croatia CRO

Nigeria NGA

Argentina ARG

Mexico MEX

Sweden SWE

South Korea KOR

Germany GER

Switzerland SUI

Costa Rica CRI

Serbia SRB

Brazil BRA

Senegal SEN

Colombia COL

Japan JPN

Poland POL

Panama PAN

Tunisia TUN

England ENG

Belgium BEL

All-Stars have to change, insists Carlow boss O'Brien

 

Carlow manager Turlough O'Brien. Photo: Barry Cregg/Sportsfile
Carlow manager Turlough O'Brien. Photo: Barry Cregg/Sportsfile
Martin Breheny

Martin Breheny

Carlow football manager Turlough O'Brien has called for a significant change to the format of the All-Stars scheme so that players from every county are recognised.

Frustrated by what he regards as a system that's weighted heavily against players outside the main power bases, he wants each county to get at least one nomination.

"What chance has a player from Carlow or any other county in the lower divisions of getting a nomination, let alone an award? Very little. The figures speak for themselves over the years and even more so in recent times.

"As the scheme stands, it's a clear example of extreme elitism with the top three or four counties dominating everything. I would like to see every county get at least one nomination," said O'Brien.

Nominations

That would require increasing the number of nominations from 45, a solution which O'Brien regards as practical and sensible.

"All the awards and the vast majority of nominations go to counties who were in the latter stages of the championship.

"That doesn't mean that there aren't excellent players in other counties - including in Division 4 - but they always lose out because they're not in Croke Park towards the end of the championship.

"Getting a nomination would be a huge boost for players in a lot of counties that never get a look-in. It wouldn't be tokenism to pick one from each county. In fact, it would be a great boost and wouldn't take away from the scheme in any way. Recognising every county in some way should be part of the scheme," said O'Brien.

Carlow's Seán Murphy and Paul Broderick are examples of players who performed exceptionally well this year but neither made the 45-strong nomination list from which the team will be chosen early next month.

All-Ireland football finalists, Dublin (13) and Mayo (12) have 25 nominations, with beaten semi-finalists, Tyrone (6) and Kerry (5) providing another 11.

Roscommon, Kildare, Down (two each), Monaghan, Donegal, Armagh (one each) account for the other nine.

Irish Independent

Sport Newsletter

The best sport action straight to your inbox every morning.

Editor's Choice

Also in Sport