Sitcom likely to continue – but will its millions of fans buy into remake?

David Bauder

Charlie Sheen is gone, but his sitcom Two And A Half Men is likely to stick around.

Although the eight-year-old show is ageing and revolved around Sheen's playboy character Charlie Harper, Warner Bros Television and CBS have every incentive to try to keep it going after producers fired him on Monday.

The show, for one, is a huge moneymaker -- it is the most popular comedy on the air, and in syndication in the US. But the more important question might be whether viewers will buy a remade show next fall.

There are numerous examples of shows losing stars and plugging along with other actors, though not necessarily in the same roles. Just ask Dick Sargent, Jimmy Smits, Farrah Fawcett-Majors, Sandy Duncan and, yes, even Sheen.

In Sheen's case, he worked for two years on ABC's Spin City, essentially replacing original star Michael J Fox in 2000 when Parkinson's disease made it impossible for Fox to continue.


NYPD Blue continued for a decade with Smits after its original lead actor, David Caruso, decided he wanted to try movies.

Farrah Fawcett-Majors was television's biggest new star when she left Charlie's Angels in 1977, although she made guest appearances afterward. Ladd joined the cast the same year, with the show running another four seasons.

Duncan had a tough task in 1987 -- replace Valerie Harper in Valerie. It was eventually renamed The Hogan Family and went off the air in 1991. Suzanne Somers left Three's Company in 1981, and was replaced by Priscilla Barnes. The show ended in 1984.

Each of those new actors played different characters than the ones who left.

That wasn't the case with Sargent, who moved right in as Bewitched star Elizabeth Montgomery's husband Darrin Stephens when the original Darrin, Dick York, left in 1969. The show ended in 1972.

Even if Two And A Half Men returns, it's highly unlikely that there will be a new Charlie Harper. The hard-partying Sheen embodied the character; some suggested it was written with his real-life persona in mind.

Viewers wouldn't buy it, said Robert Thompson, director of the Bleier Center for Television and Popular Culture at Syracuse University.

"It would be like if your mother said, 'the role of your father is now being played by so-and-so', and not 'I've left your father and here is my new guy,'" Thompson said.

What would be important is for the show to keep the same 'Odd Couple plus a kid' dynamic embodied by the suave Harper, his nebbish brother portrayed by Jon Cryer and the Cryer character's son, he said.

Characters coming and going in major series are no longer unusual, particularly if the series stays on the air for a long time.

When ER came to an end on NBC, it had a completely different cast than when it started. Law & Order rotated actors.

Even the deaths of stars haven't stopped networks from keeping shows alive. Chico And The Man tried recasting when star Freddie Prinze committed suicide. And when John Ritter died of a heart ailment, ABC made the death of his character a central plot point in 8 Simple Rules.

For TV networks and producers, there's much less risk to keeping proven concepts alive than to hope audiences embrace something new.

And it's not as if Two And A Half Men has worn out its welcome. The Nielsen Company said it was the highest-rated comedy on television last week, even though CBS aired a rerun because production on the show had stopped.

Warner Bros and CBS already made an investment in the show's future -- the cast is signed for next season, including Sheen, until his firing.


Given all the attention paid to the story in the past few months, there's almost certain to be a big interest in a recast show if it premieres next fall.

"If I were an agent trying to sell my client to the producers, I would be making the point about how stupid it would be to take all the cultural equity and interest in this show and not bring it back again," Thompson said.

Executives at CBS and Warner Bros had no public comments on Two and a Half Men.

The Hollywood executives have some time. The real deadline for a decision comes in May, when the networks announce their fall schedules and begin selling advertising time.