| 7.7°C Dublin

Close

Premium

Historic legal ruling could have chilling civil rights repercussions

Close

Mr Justice Adrian Hardiman, pictured, says that Judge Peter Kelly speaks on behalf of the judges

Mr Justice Adrian Hardiman, pictured, says that Judge Peter Kelly speaks on behalf of the judges

Mr Justice Adrian Hardiman, pictured, says that Judge Peter Kelly speaks on behalf of the judges

Seismic shift as Supreme Court splits on key ruling," proclaimed the Irish Independent. "Landmark decision rewrites evidence rulebook," trumpeted the Irish Times. The headlines varied, but it was immediately apparent that the response of the media was unanimous: the decision of the Supreme Court by four votes to three to overturn its earlier ruling in the Kenny case in 1990 instantly acquired the status of the first great landmark case of the 21st century.

In the words of Mr Justice Hardiman, "this is as significant a case on criminal law and evidence as any that has come before the Court in the last 25 years. It affects in an important way the rights and liberties of every citizen".


Most Watched





Privacy