Saturday 19 January 2019

Don't let bubble distract us from challenges ahead

A new financial crash may not be coming, but we face an unsustainable gap in housing stock

What is happening now is a scarcity of housing driving up its price. Photo: Stock Image
What is happening now is a scarcity of housing driving up its price. Photo: Stock Image

Ronan Lyons

Last week, the ratings agency S&P issued a report on Ireland. That report included a diagnosis of the housing market that was interpreted as predicting a "soft landing".

Of course, many scoffed - remembering similar predictions from the mid-2000s. You could be forgiven for thinking of Michael Gove's infamous line, just before Brexit, that "people in this country have had enough of experts".

But whatever our opinions on ratings agencies and how they performed in the run-up to the crash, the S&P report should not be dismissed as external analysts making the same mistakes all over again. Rather, our reaction to the report might tell us more about ourselves than the rating agencies. In particular, we need to ensure we are not fighting the last war. To explain, what happened, the Irish housing market 1995-2012 was a classic credit-fuelled bubble and crash. It is understandable - it is important - that we should be very careful not to make the same mistake again.

But those steps have largely already been taken. The Central Bank mortgage rules effectively bring the Irish mortgage market back to the system it had, quite successfully, under the building societies from the mid-19th Century all the way through to the 1990s. Lenders and borrowers must link mortgages, and thus housing prices, to the real economy, as measured by savings and incomes.

What is happening now is a scarcity of housing driving up its price. There is strong demand but not enough supply. The big difference between the 2010s increase in prices and the 2000s one is that, then, sale prices rose but rents did not (or at least not nearly to the same extent). That is a classic sign of a bubble.

Now, however, rent and sale prices are rising almost one-for-one in line with each other. This is why it is important to distinguish between bubble-crash cycles and more regular boom-bust cycles. Don't believe anyone who tells you that they can end boom-bust cycles. As long as humans are humans, their confidence in the future will ebb and flow.

We can be more confident, though, about bubble-crash cycles. I need to be careful here, too, as I wouldn't feel comfortable in stating that we can stop them entirely. But we can make sure that the mistakes that happened 1995-2012 - in particular, allowing people to borrow too much relative to their income and to the value of the property - don't happen again.

This is why there should be no link between S&P talking about supply and demand in the Irish housing market now and headlines from 12 or 14 years ago. If you're fighting a different war, it makes no sense to be thinking about how you might have done better in the last one.

The graph below shows the ratio of average price of property in Dublin to elsewhere in the country. Up to the mid-1980s, there was effectively no ''Dublin premium''. Granted, properties in the capital may have been a bedroom fewer and a smaller garden. But the price paid was effectively the same everwhere.

Since the 1990s, though, a growing Dublin premium has emerged. If current trends continue, it is likely that Dublin property prices will be twice as expensive as those elsewhere in the country by 2020.

Suppose you could draw a straight line from 1995 to 2012 and ignore the credit bubble and crash. What would stick out then in a graph of housing prices? It would be that, over the last few decades, prices have risen above inflation - especially in the capital. This is a new phenomenon but not one unique to Ireland. Our high-income peers have also seen prices increase steadily in recent decades after typically a century of ups and downs but no overall trend. Detailed research into this reveals that zoning restrictions have limited the ability of housing supply to meet demand.

In Ireland's case, things were fine in the housing market... as long as we didn't have significant population growth.

The last generation has shown - credit bubble and extraordinary tax breaks aside - that housing supply is incapable of meeting demand in Ireland. Where supply has come on stream, it has typically been new estates on greenfield sites at the edges of cities or further down the national road network. This is unsustainable. We already have far more family homes than families in this country. But we do not have nearly enough homes for our households of one or two persons. These smaller households are now the majority. But apartments form only one in seven of our housing stock.

The recent bubble should not distract us from the huge challenges that lie ahead.

Sunday Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Don't Miss