Alex Horton: ''Die Hard' claim won't settle fiery debate over best Christmas story'
No matter where you fall in the debate, the statement from 20th Century Fox is unlikely to settle it.
The studio said this week that the Bruce Willis action flick 'Die Hard', which it produced 30 years ago, is not just any Christmas story, but: "The greatest Christmas story ever told."
The studio made the claim in a new trailer it released for the film this week, with the holiday season in full swing.
Please log in or register with Independent.ie for free access to this article.
The debate over whether 'Die Hard' is a Christmas story has raged for years.
What was perhaps once a tongue-in-cheek pushback to the G-rated fare the holiday season has typically been known for, has helped give the movie an indelible association with the holidays.
The film now plays in movie theatres the world over during the holidays. There is a corresponding illustrated book, 'A Die Hard Christmas'.
Bruce Willis has weighed in: "'Die Hard' is not a Christmas movie. It's a goddamn Bruce Willis movie," he said in July.
News media articles now chronicle the debate every December. Google trends show that searches for 'Die Hard' and 'Christmas' spike every December.
The film was not released around Christmas; it came out in July. But it takes place during Christmas.
Hero John McClane begins the movie on a trip to California, to visit his children during the holiday and win back the affection of his wife. But the film's villain, Hans Gruber, uses a holiday party as a setting to take hostages.
Steven E de Souza, the film's screenwriter, is firmly in the "'Die Hard' is a Christmas movie" camp.
He told 'The Washington Post' that the film's producer, Joel Silver, had predicted that the movie would get played at Christmastime for years.
De Souza also made a chart in an attempt to argue that 'White Christmas' is not a Christmas movie if 'Die Hard' isn't.
The entirety of 'Die Hard' takes place during the holiday, de Souza noted, not just the final reel, like 'White Christmas'.
It has three Christmas songs - 'Let It Snow', 'Winter Wonderland' and 'Christmas in Hollis' - to two in 'White Christmas'.
Academics and historians have weighed in.
"Christmas is a liminal, ritualised period of carnivalesque inversion during which underdogs and the powerless are briefly elevated above hierarchical structures," historian Greg Jenner wrote on Twitter.
"John McClane is a classic Christmas underdog triumphing over selfish venality."
The debate is sure to continue online. (© The Washington Post)