Saturday 25 November 2017

State must show mercy to ordinary mortgage-holders

If a household charge is eventually brought in, homeowners should get a refund on stamp duty, writes Marc Coleman

Disparate and desperate. So far, more talk than walk, the campaign for mortgage debt forgiveness has not been a cohesive affair. Then again, it's hardly surprising. As the presidential election silly season shows, the media favours celebrity over substance, and process over policy.

Having ignored well-argued articles on the issue, it turned on the spotlights for Morgan Kelly's address to the Kilkenny Arts Festival. But Morgan's idea for tackling the debt crisis -- reducing the budget deficit to zero in less than a year -- is so bizarrely right-wing that even Colonel Pinochet would have baulked at it. Brian Hayes can hardly be blamed for giving suggestions from that quarter a wide berth.

The first barrier to any successful debate on the topic is terminology. With its air of wealthy professionals cadging tax euros off us to stay in €2m homes, the term "debt forgiveness" is unhelpful. Fortunately, a better narrative exists, one that is clear and compelling. Forget "debt forgiveness", what Ireland needs now is a simple cry, "Give us our money back". Instead of a pathetic cry for some undeserved mercy, we should be confidently asserting our rights. It isn't the mortgage-holders -- those forced to pay small fortunes in stamp duty to buy homes as the Government urged them to do -- who should ask forgiveness. It is the State which forced those taxes upon them and that forgiveness can only flow from a policy that is a much more workable alternative to debt forgiveness: a rebate on residential stamp duty.

Please sign in or register with Independent.ie for free access to Opinions.

Sign In

Promoted Links

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Don't Miss