Saturday 25 May 2019

Dave Kenny: Terrible lie by troubled teen led to horrific death

A tragedy not unlike a John B Keane novel has blighted the lives of loving, heartbroken parents, writes Dave Kenny

Dave Kenny

STEphen Lyne was just 17 when he bled his life away on a grass verge, metres from his home. He had been stabbed in the back after being falsely accused of raping a teenage girl. The girl later admitted her claim was "a blatant, disgusting lie".



His killer, Shane Regan, will never be brought to trial. In August 2010, he died after falling down the stairs of his rented home. Regan -- also 17 at the time -- was a distant cousin of Stephen's. That relationship counted for nothing when he drove a knife 11.5cm into his victim's body in a Kerry laneway on June 18, 2009.

The chain of events leading up to that night wouldn't seem out of place in a John B Keane tragedy.

"Stephen never knew why he was being killed," his mother Lotte says. "He kept asking Regan, 'Why are you doing this, cousin?' Regan gave him no explanation."

The girl who cried rape -- Jessica Klok -- was then 15 and going out with Regan. In March, she apologised for her lie during the trial of Martin Ollo (19). The Estonian student, of An Doireann Aileann, Killarney, had pleaded not guilty to two counts of conspiring with Regan, of Droumkerry, Fossa, Killarney on the nights of June 16/17 and June 17/18 to assault Stephen, causing him harm.

On March 2, Ollo was found guilty of the first charge and given three years at Tralee Circuit Criminal Court. Before sentencing, the judge acknowledged that Ollo had not intended for Stephen to be killed and was not directly responsible for his death. The trial had heard that Ollo did not know Regan had a knife on the night Stephen died.

The pair planned to lure Stephen to Scrahan Mews, off Ross Road, Killarney, on June 16 so that Regan could give him a beating.

"Martin Ollo came on a family holiday with us. We travelled across Europe for a month. How could he betray Stephen like that?" asks Stephen's mother, Lotte.

"Stephen couldn't see badness in anyone. He was too kind and was always helping people. Everyone loved him. He just hadn't learned to read people properly. He was only 17."

This is the first time Lotte -- who is Regional Business Development Executive with financial firm MCN Associates -- has spoken about the full extent of her son's death and the family's ordeal that followed. Now she wants to set up a foundation to stop delinquency before it happens. "Children are not born evil," she says.

Lotte (45), who is Danish, moved to Ireland in 1982 and met her husband Denis in Killarney four years later. They married in 1988 and had their first daughter, Tasha (23), in 1989.

In 1990 they moved to Denmark, where their other five children -- Benjamin (11), Jonas (16), Mathias (17), Stephen (pronounced 'Stefan') and Sofie (21) -- were born. In 2001, the family returned to Castle Falls, Killarney: a highly desirable address in a county renowned for its beautiful scenery. The Lynes wanted their children to learn about their Irish roots. Tragically, one of those family roots led to Shane Regan.

"Stephen had only known Regan for about six months. He was delighted when he found out that they were third cousins. He was really proud of his family," says Lotte.

Stephen, Ollo and Regan were part of a large group of teens who hung around together during the early summer of 2009. The court heard that Regan had a reputation for being domineering, violent and manipulative.

During the June Bank Holiday weekend Regan's girlfriend, Jessica Klok, was spotted in Killarney Demesne with Stephen. "They were walking and talking. Stephen was always very kind to Jessica," says Lotte.

Klok later told Regan that Stephen had dragged her into the woods, put a knife to her throat and raped her. It was completely untrue. An enraged Regan repeated the accusation to Stephen's sister Sofie, saying he was "going to get Stephen". Sofie warned Lotte of the threat.

"I absolutely knew the rape claim wasn't true. I knew my son. Everyone who knew Stephen said he wasn't capable of such a thing," says Lotte. "I told him he was in danger and to stay off the streets."

Her fears were well founded. She and Denis foiled the first ambush on June 16 when they picked up Stephen on the road and brought him home.

The court heard that, in the early hours of June 18, Ollo went with Stephen to Scrahan Mews to smoke cannabis with Regan.

"No alcohol or drugs were found in the toxicology tests on Stephen. Reports that he had been smoking cannabis the night he died -- or around that time -- were not true," says Lotte.

Ollo said Regan hit Stephen in the back and chased him on to Ross Road. He heard Stephen screaming, asking why Regan was attacking him. He was dying from a single knife wound to his back, which had cut through his kidney, spleen and arteries.

It was around 1.20am and, by this time, the Lynes were worried as Stephen wasn't answering his phone. Lotte was in Dublin for work, so Denis went to search for him. He came across the crime scene and was devastated by what he saw.

"Denis has lived through the agony of losing his eldest son, but he has a heavier cross to bear. He constantly lives through the recurring nightmare of seeing the ambulance, the police, and the flashing lights. As he came upon the scene, he saw his son's lifeless body lying on the grass.

"He relives that night over and over again, constantly blaming himself for not being there to protect his Stephen."

Lotte will never forget receiving the news of her son's death.

"I was staying at the Burlington. At 3.30am, two gardai knocked at my door. They said I needed to call home -- they did not know why. Denis picked up my call and told me what happened and the world stopped. 'It is Stephen, he is dead, and he has been stabbed.'

"I remember slowly sliding to the floor as I cried out. The lady garda reached for me, repeating, 'I am sorry, I did not know.' The other garda sat with a stunned look on his face. I remember putting up my hand as if to physically stop the terrible news from being a reality, thinking that I could somehow, by pure force, hold back the finality of those words: my son is dead.

"The gardai and hotel staff were very kind and organised a cab to take me to the airport to get a flight to Kerry. There was hassle at the Ryanair desk as I didn't have my passport with me. After several phone calls, they eventually let me buy a ticket.

"I spent two hours, on my own, in Dublin Airport. I was miles away from my husband and children in the worst moments of our lives. I needed to be there to protect them from this horrendous truth.

"I phoned my parents and Stephen's best friends to tell them what had happened. Afterwards, I went to the ladies' and locked myself into a cubicle, shaking and sobbing as the pain raked through my body. I made several more trips to the toilet to collapse in tears before my flight was called.

"That flight was the longest 20 minutes of my life. I sat alone with tears flowing down my face. No-one came near me. Later, as Denis and I drove down Ross Road, I saw the tent that covered my son's body. I have no words that will do justice to how I felt."

Lotte speaks kindly of the other players in this tragedy. She bears Ollo no ill will, although he never expressed remorse to them directly.

Klok wrote to the Lynes after Ollo's trial, finally apologising for what she had done. Lotte has sympathy for her. "Jessica was a very troubled girl back then. There are only losers in this story."

Regan was never charged in relation to the stabbing. The trial heard he had "gone to his grave" believing Stephen had raped Klok. She told the court that he had admitted killing Stephen to her. Ollo would have been willing to testify against him had he ever been prosecuted for homicide.

Lotte was disappointed at the length of time it took for a case to be heard.

"Stephen's brothers and sisters have faced a lot of heartache, very young," she says. "We waited for over two years for justice. The truth came out during the trial. Our son has been totally vindicated from the lies that were said about him. People have admitted their involvement and guilt. We are thankful for the hard work that the gardai have carried out to establish that truth.

"In memory of our son we are in the process of starting up the Stephen Lyne Foundation, which will focus on children and young people. It will aim to prevent youngsters from turning to violence and crime.

"This will be done through a number of initiatives which we will announce in due time. We also want to ensure that our son is remembered for the person he really was: an honest and loyal young man."

In the meantime, the Lynes are coping with their grief "bit by bit".

"We only cleared Stephen's room last summer and that was because we were moving house. I used to sit there looking at his posters, touching his belongings, and the pain of losing him would take my breath away."

Lotte shouldered Stephen's coffin at his funeral. "It was something I had to do. I brought him into this world and had to carry him to his last resting place, no matter how heartbreaking that burden was."

That physical burden lasted only a few minutes. Lotte and her family will carry the heavier burden of their loss forever.

(If you wish to contact Lotte about the Stephen Lyne Foundation, please email her at lotte@mcnassociates.ie)

Sunday Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Don't Miss