| 10°C Dublin

Families face €5,000 bill to make drinking water safe


Environment Minister Alan Kelly launches the lead strategy in Dublin yesterday. Photo: Damien Eagers

Environment Minister Alan Kelly launches the lead strategy in Dublin yesterday. Photo: Damien Eagers

Dr Kevin Kelleher: better to breastfeed babies than give a bottle, due to lead in pipes

Dr Kevin Kelleher: better to breastfeed babies than give a bottle, due to lead in pipes


Environment Minister Alan Kelly launches the lead strategy in Dublin yesterday. Photo: Damien Eagers

Tens of thousands of families will be saddled with bills of more than €5,000 after the Government admitted the country's lead crisis is far more severe than previously feared.

Some 200,000 homes, as well as an unknown number of schools, hospitals, creches, prisons and nursing homes, are plumbed using lead piping that poses a health risk to occupants and particularly the very young.

The alarming figures prompted a senior HSE official to warn women against bottle feeding their children.

Environment Minister Alan Kelly now wants to roll out a grant scheme by the end of the summer aimed at providing assistance to low-income households forced to replace lead plumbing in their homes.

The move comes despite the Government insisting as recently as last September that none would be introduced.

Government sources also admitted last night that although the Environment Protection Agency (EPA) has been warning about lead levels for years, the extent of the problem in public buildings is still unknown.

The HSE, Department of Education and other public bodies have now been ordered to audit their buildings and identify any issues.

Irish Water has started writing to 28,000 homes warning of a potential problem, after lead piping was discovered during the installation of meters.

As many as 200,000 are suspected of having a problem.

The Government has been strongly criticised for waiting years before tackling the crisis, despite repeated warnings about the dangers of lead.

Lead pipes may have been used in mains connections and inside plumbing in properties built up to and including the 1970s. In the 1970s alone, some 167,230 homes were built.

The HSE was also dragged into the controversy after claiming that families affected should consider only breastfeeding their children.

Daily Digest Newsletter

Get ahead of the day with the morning headlines at 7.30am and Fionnán Sheahan's exclusive take on the day's news every afternoon, with our free daily newsletter.

This field is required

"This is a very strong message again that it is far better to breastfeed than to bottle," said the HSE's Professor Kevin Kelleher. "With the levels we are talking about, there is a possibility that it can cause neuro-developmental delays for some children," he added.

Asked about families who decide not to remove lead pipes, the Environment Minister said: "My advice is you shouldn't ignore this, especially if you have a young family."

Mr Kelly said the grants scheme would be closely modelled on the septic tank remediation scheme and would enable households with incomes up to €50,000 to receive 80pc of the costs back, up to a maximum of €4,000.

There will be a separate band in place for those earning €50,001 to €75,000, with financial help to cover up to 50pc of the costs back, up to a maximum of €2,500.

But the minister admitted that the Government cannot say how many of the 200,000 families affected will qualify for the grants.

Families not deemed to be living on low incomes face bills of €5,000 and even higher where lead levels are greater.

A spokesman for Taoiseach Enda Kenny admitted he is "not happy" that families will be saddled with the bills but said the Government would try to provide the necessary support.

Irish Water says it could take up to 10 years and cost €250m-€300m before the issue is brought under control.

"It's really important that homeowners understand that if they live in a house which was built up to and including the 1970s that they could have lead pipes, resulting in lead in drinking water," said Irish Water's head of asset management, Jerry Grant.

"There are a number of measures which they can take to eliminate or limit the amount of lead in the drinking water."

Schools, hospitals, public buildings, offices and prisons may also be affected.

Irish Water is responsible for the public water pipes to the boundary of a property. However, the liability for replacing lead pipes within the property rests with the homeowner.

Mr Kelly said that homeowners should get their own pipes checked.

Irish Water will begin using a chemical treatment called orthophosphate from the end of the year in Limerick city. This is added to water at the treatment works, and coats the pipes with a protective layer.

This will be added to around 400 treatment plants from 2016 at a cost of €50m. While it will not eliminate the problem, it will reduce the risk.

Q&A: Why is there lead piping in homes and public buildings?

Lead was commonly used in water pipes until the 1970s, and Irish Water believes that up to 200,000 homes and an unknown number of public buildings are affected. There is no lead in the public water mains.

How does lead get into drinking water?

Water does not naturally contain lead, but a problem arises when it sits in pipes and absorbs it. Soft and warm water can pick up lead more easily.

How do I know if I have a problem?

If your plumbing is a dark grey colour, and if a silver mark is left when scratched with a knife, it could indicate a problem. If you find lead pipes, you should have your drinking water tested. Irish Water should be contacted for advice.

Am I at risk?

There is no 'safe' level of exposure. Lead can affect the development of a child's brain, leading to problems with learning, behaviour and attention. It may also harm the kidneys, and has been linked to cancer. There is no issue with bathing, toilet flushing, laundry and dishwashing.

If I find lead, what should I do?

To make up infant feeds, use bottled water - but not 'natural mineral water' as it contains high levels of salt. It should be boiled for one minute before use. Running the water from the kitchen tap can also flush out the lead, but replacing the pipes is the only measure that will eliminate the problem.

What are the Government and Irish Water doing?

Irish Water will begin using a chemical to treat water in Limerick this year, and in 400 supplies from 2016, which provides a protective coating to pipes and reduces the risk. The Government's strategy requires public buildings to be assessed for lead, and a grants scheme will be available to homeowners.