News Irish News

Monday 21 January 2019

Prosecutors call for tougher penalty after Irish backpacker's scalp and ear torn off in workplace accident

Annie Dunne was injured while working in Australia in 2015
Annie Dunne was injured while working in Australia in 2015 Newsdesk Newsdesk

Prosecutors are calling for a tougher penalty to be handed down to an Australian packing company after an Irish backpacker's scalp and ear were torn off by a conveyor belt.

Tipperary native Annie Dunne suffered extensive injuries when her hair got caught in a mechanical conveyor belt at a packing shed in Shepparton Victoria in November, 2015.

Packing company Kalafatis Packing pleaded guilty to failing to provide a safe system of work and was fined $50,000.

According to, prosecutors are now appealing the sentence.

Acting Director of Public Prosecutions Gavin Silbert QC, who lodged an appeal on Wednesday, said that the sentence was “manifestly inadequate”.

It is understood Ms Dunne - originally from Kilkeary outside Nenagh - was working to fulfil the 89 days of regional work required to extend her working holiday visa for a second year at the time.

'The Age' newspaper in Australia reported at the time that Ms Dunne was cleaning the conveyor belt which was used to deliver pears for distribution when her hair became entangled in a rotating drive shaft.

She suffered extensive damage to her scalp and one of her ears in the incident.

In January, WorkSafe’s health and safety executive director Marnie Williams said the circumstances of the incident were appalling, according to

It's believed that workers were required to clean the conveyors while they were energised and moving.

“This truly was a shocking incident that has changed this young woman’s life in a split second,” Ms Williams told

“It’s staggering that workers were expected to clean machines which were still in operation.”

She said the labour hire business engaged workers for the packing shed and left them exposed to risk of “serious injury and death”.

Ms Williams said there was a “blatant risk” of serious injury from entanglement, crushing or entrapment with both conveyors in the shed.

Online Editors

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News