Monday 23 April 2018

Pros and cons of city location for ambitious project

Eilish O'Regan

Eilish O'Regan


• The hospital would be in the city centre, which has good transport links.

• It's beside the adult Mater Hospital, which would provide specialist services.

• It was backed by a HSE task force and an international expert group.

• The site has been the subject of analysis by five other consultants' reports.

• €35m has already been spent on the project.

• It has the backing of the government and Health Minister James Reilly.


• Bus services can be unreliable, and Metro North -- which would carry large numbers of staff and patients -- is on hold.

• The site is small at just two hectares, and doesn't allow for future expansion.

• The building is too big, and has a negative impact on the city's skyline.

• Opponents include retired doctors who say it should be built on a bigger site, ideally near the M50.

• Planning permission has been refused, and the Mater Adult hospital needs a helipad for emergency cases, which would serve both hospitals and quickly transport patients from outside Dublin.

Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News