Tuesday 20 November 2018

Posthumous pardon 'clears historical record'

President Michael D Higgins and John Joyce, great grandson of John Joyce, who was murdered in 1882. Photo: Maxwells
President Michael D Higgins and John Joyce, great grandson of John Joyce, who was murdered in 1882. Photo: Maxwells
Ian Begley

Ian Begley

An innocent man hanged for murder almost 140 years ago has been granted a pardon by the President.

The posthumous pardon issued to Myles Joyce by Michael D Higgins is the first granted by an Irish President in a case pre-dating the foundation of the State.

The Co Galway native was one of three men hanged in December 1882 for the murders of five members of the same family, also called Joyce, in the townland of Maamtrasna on the Co Galway-Co Mayo border.

Shortly before their executions, two of the men confessed to the crimes but insisted their co-accused Joyce was innocent.

Their admissions were deemed insufficient to postpone or revoke the execution order.

The confessions, combined with concerns on the reliability of other evidence presented at trial, have long raised serious doubts about the safety of his conviction.

Mr Joyce was a Gaelic speaker, yet his trial was heard in English, a language he did not understand.

Alleged eyewitnesses in the case were also awarded significant compensation under the direction of the then lord lieutenant of Ireland.

A legal expert commissioned by the Irish government in 2015 to examine the circumstances of the case concluded that Mr Joyce, whose Irish name was Maolra Seoighe, was wrongfully convicted.

Following the assessment of University College Dublin academic Dr Niamh Howlin, Justice Minister Charlie Flanagan last week sought and secured the backing of Cabinet colleagues to recommend the granting of a presidential pardon.

President Higgins, who has a long-standing interest in the case, signed a warrant granting a posthumous pardon, under article 13.6 of the Irish Constitution, at Áras an Uachtaráin. The pardon is only the fifth issued by the State since 1937, and only the second granted posthumously.

Mr Joyce was related to members of the Joyce family murdered at Maamtrasna, and a number of their descendants attended the ceremony at the Áras.

President Higgins described the trial as a "shameful episode in Ireland and Britain's history".

He said: "Deliberate actions had to be taken to corrupt witnesses, bribes were spread and, in addition, Myles could not speak English.

"The verdict of this grave injustice indicated that Irish people could really be treated in an inferior way under British rule."

He hailed the "simmering outrage and steely determination" of those who had campaigned to have the case revisited.

Mr Higgins said the pardon would "correct the historical record".

Irish Independent

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News