Wednesday 21 November 2018

Government loses vote as digital age of consent now 16

Children’s online safety has been compromised by politicians after the digital age of consent was set at 16, leading groups have claimed. (stock picture)
Children’s online safety has been compromised by politicians after the digital age of consent was set at 16, leading groups have claimed. (stock picture)
Kevin Doyle

Kevin Doyle

Children's online safety has been compromised by politicians after the digital age of consent was set at 16, campaigners have claimed.

The Government suffered an embarrassing Dáil defeat last night with its proposal to set the age at which a child can give their consent to a website to collect and profile their information at 13.

By 56 votes to 51, it was decided the age should be raised to 16.

Justice Minister Charlie Flanagan had the support of AAA-PBP, the Social Democrats and a number of Independent TDs, including Clare Daly and Mick Wallace, but 15 Fine Gael TDs were not present for the vote.

Government sources noted that some TDs were absent because they were attending committees, adding that 21 representatives from Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin and Labour were also missing.

Those three parties joined forces to raise the age despite opposition from groups including the ISPCC, Children's Rights Alliance, SpunOut.ie and Barnardo's.

In a joint statement, the organisations said the move "will create significant risks to child safety, will not be enforceable and will remove the onus from industry to protect the children availing of their services".

"Risks associated with setting the age at 16 include impeding the prosecution of perpetrators of online grooming, removing an onus on online service providers to provide age filters designed to protect young people from inappropriate grooming and content, and encouraging young people to lie about their age in order to access services," they said.

Barnardo's chief executive Fergus Finlay said the decision "fails to address the uncomfortable realities about children's online use".

Meanwhile, the Irish Heart Foundation welcomed a separate amendment to the Data Protection Bill which will make the micro-targeting of children by junk-food marketers using data harvested by social media platforms a criminal offence.

Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Also in this section