Friday 17 August 2018

'Please don't put a price on my life' - seriously ill grandmother begs HSE to make 'miracle' drug available

Marion with her granddaughter Mia
Marion with her granddaughter Mia
Kathy Armstrong

Kathy Armstrong

A grandmother with a rare lung condition has urged the HSE to make a "miracle" drug available, saying she and others are being denied a chance of a healthier life.

Marion Kelly (53) suffers from Alpha-1, a genetic condition that causes serious lung and liver problems.

She was one of 21 people here who were taking the drug, Respreeza, as part of a trial and is calling on the HSE to reverse a decision not to fund the drug.

Marion, who is from Nenagh in Co Tipperary, told Independent.ie: "I was born with Alpha-1 but it didn't actually surface until I was in my 30s, I started to feel breathless and I was actually treated for asthma for a couple of years until I was diagnsoed.

"I'd been a hairdresser and I owned my own salon but I had to give it up because my health went rapidly downhill."

Marion - who also relies on an oxygen treatment - said she was offered a new lease of life 11 years ago when she was chosen to participate in the trail of Repreeza.

She explained: "The trial was given to 21 of us and we were able to take it for as long as the trial continued.

"It was fantastic, I could go back to things like shopping independently, gardening and doing things for myself.

"I had a new lease of life, it felt like a miracle.

"Before that I would have been in and out of hospital six or seven times a year but with Respreeza I think I was in hospital just once over three years so I felt like I had my freedom back."

The group were informed 22 months ago that the trial was coming to an end but had to wait month-to-month to find out when.

In September the drug trial was finished but a further supply has been made available to those on trial but there has been confusion over who will administer it recently.

"It's licenced in other countries and while the HSE and Health Minister might claim it's not worth it then how did I feel so much better for those eleven years?," Marion said.


"I've only been off Respreeza for six weeks and already I can feel a massive difference in my health.

"They're putting a price on our lives, if we don't get this drug we will die younger, they are denying us the chance to have a fairly healthy life."

Marion said she wants to watch her granddaughter Mia (six months) grow up.

She said: "I'm already having trouble lifting Mia, I've always pushed myself to do things and not let this hold me back but one night it really upset me that I'm only 53 and there's so many things I can't do."

She continued to say: "Every chest infection takes away a little piece of my lungs that won't recover.

"When Orkambi (a drug for people with Cystic Fibrosis) was approved earlier this year it did give me hope, I'm not giving up this fight.

"I feel there's a price on my head but I think my life is worth more than €80,000."

Previously the National Centre of Pharmacoeconomics said the drug "wasn't value for money" after it carried out a drug assessment.

Professor Michael Barry, the centre’s clinical director, said that the decision not to reimburse the drug was not solely based on its cost however, saying the centre primarily found the evidence from the clinical trial was not strong enough.

While there was a benefit in terms of lung density on CT scanning, unfortunately clinical outcomes in terms of lung function tests, quality of life, exacerbations and indeed survival; there was no impact of this drug on any of those parameters," he said.

"That in conjunction with the high cost of the drug - it can be anything over €80,000 per patient per year, we felt that it wasn't value for money."

A HSE spokeswoman said: "The HSE has agreed to a temporary funding arrangement of six months for the administration of Respreeza to those affected by manufacturer’s  recent decision to modify its compassionate access programme.

"This decision is to allow the patients remain on the drug while they transition to an alternative care pathway."

For more information about Marion or to support her petition to have Resprezza made available in Ireland, please visit here.

Online Editors

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News