Wednesday 21 March 2018

Former minister Michael McDowell guest speaker at Thomas Byrne Christmas party

*Trial hears the then Justice Minister gave speech at party in Four Seasons

Former Minister for Justice Michael McDowell and former solicitor Thomas Byrne (inset)
Former Minister for Justice Michael McDowell and former solicitor Thomas Byrne (inset)
Former solicitor Thomas Byrne arriving at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court yesterday
Former Minister for Justice Michael McDowell S.C at the launch of Solicitors for Europe at The Shelbourne Hotel, Dublin.

Conor Gallagher

FORMER solicitor Thomas Byrne was introduced to former Irish Nationwide Building Society CEO Michael Fingleton in a private box in Croke Park before the finalisation of a €4.5m loan, a court heard.

And the then-Minister for Justice Michael McDowell was a guest speaker at Thomas Byrne's Christmas party in the Four Seasons, the trial was told.

Mr Byrne (47), of Walkinstown Road, Crumlin, is accused of theft and fraud offences totalling €51.8m. The charges allege he transferred clients' homes into his name and then used them as collateral for property loans.

He has pleaded not guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to 51 counts of theft, forgery, using forged documents and deception between 2004 and 2007.

A former manager of the Dundrum branch of Irish Nationwide Building Society detailed how Mr Byrne borrowed a total of €11.4m from the society over a 15-month period in 2006 and 2007.

Branch manager Colin Walsh said he had met Mr Byrne through another solicitor in 2005, and that he had attended a Christmas party in the Four Seasons being hosted jointly by Mr Byrne and property developer John Kelly. He said Michael McDowell was a speaker at the event, along with comedian Ardal O'Hanlon.

Mr Walsh told defence counsel Damien Colgan SC that he had socialised with Mr Byrne and would have been in his Lad Lane apartment on social occasions. He agreed that he may have been at the apartment late into the night but said he couldn't remember if he had ever stayed over. He said Mr Byrne had also brought him and several other business associates to the Ryder Cup golf tournament. Mr Walsh said Mr Byrne's third loan application for €4.5m required the approval of Irish Nationwide CEO Michael Fingleton because of its size.

The witness said he introduced Mr Byrne to Mr Fingleton in a box in Croke Park, and that the loan was later granted. However, he said the meeting and the loan approval were not linked. The former internal auditor with Irish Nationwide, Killian McMahon, told the court via video link from Los Angeles that many of the properties used as security by Mr Byrne were worthless to the society as it emerged it did not have "first legal charge" over them. The society granted a €4.8m loan to Mr Byrne in 2006 based on nine properties being offered as security. Mr McMahon said it later transpired that none of these properties was valid collateral.


The court heard that on October 15, 2007, Irish Nationwide had sent out a large number of letters to clients' solicitors asking them to provide proof of ownership of their homes.

Mr Walsh told prosecuting counsel Remy Farrell SC that this was prompted by the breaking of the "Michael Lynn story". The court was told Lynn was a solicitor who borrowed money using bogus security in similar alleged circumstances. He said that Mr Byrne got one of these letters and responded to Mr Walsh by asking if there was a "witch-hunt" in progress.

Mr Walsh said he responded that if the accused turned in the title deeds "all would be solved".

He said when Mr Byrne failed to provide proof of ownership, he called to the solicitor's office but no one was there. He then called to his home on Lad Lane and "saw that the whole apartment was emptied out".

The next day he went back to the solicitor's office and was told by someone to refer matters to the Law Society.

The trial continues before Judge Patrick McCartan and jury of seven men and five women.


Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News