News Irish News

Saturday 25 January 2020

Fitzgerald and PR firm came up with flawed wording

the constitutional amendment and the scheme of the Adoption Bill.

Transport Minister Leo Varadkar distanced himself rom the embarrassing ruling and insisted "nothing had gone wrong" with the Fine Gael campaign that he was directing.

"This decision solely relates to the information campaign of the Department of Children. It doesn't relate to the Yes campaign run by Fine Gael and the Yes campaign run by all of the children's organisations," he said.

But after pointing the finger firmly in the direction of Ms Fitzgerald, Mr Varadkar said he "did not know" who was responsible for getting the wording wrong.

In the court papers, an affidavit by Elizabeth Canavan, assistant secretary general at the department, shows the content for the website emerged from a list of questions developed by the minister and another list of questions provided by PR firm MKC.

The Government drafted in Gerard Angley, a senior civil servant at the Department of Finance who worked on the Stability Treaty.

Mr Angley said in court papers that it was clear Ms Fitzgerald's department was "consistently conscious of the legal environment, including McKenna".

A meeting was held in early August to brief officials, advisers and all consultants on the compatibility of the children's referendum information campaign with McKenna.

But the Supreme Court granted engineer Mark McCrystal, who challenged the Government's €1.1m spend, a declaration that the State acted wrongfully in spending money on the information campaign in a manner that was not fair, equal or impartial.

The High Court had previously said the material used in the Government's campaign was "neutral, balanced and had the primary aim of informing the public about the forthcoming referendum".

Ms Fitzgerald told the Seanad that her department had acted in good faith and with the best intentions to comply with the McKenna judgment.


Mr Varadkar said there was no question of the referendum not going ahead, after five Independent TDs -- four of them confirmed Yes voters -- called on the Government to postpone it.

The Government was shielded from a political backlash because all parties in the Dail are supporting the Yes side.

Independent Donegal South West TD Thomas Pringle said that any additional cost incurred following the Supreme Court ruling was the Government's own fault.

He was supported by fellow Independents Tom Fleming, Finian McGrath, Shane Ross and Mattie McGrath.

Mr McGrath is the only TD in the Dail who is calling for a No vote.

Irish Independent

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News