Monday 22 January 2018

Occupants ordered to leave 'unauthorised hotel' with 17 people sleeping in one room, 36 in basement

The rooms at The Pines, Lehaunstown, Cabinteely. Photo:
The rooms at The Pines, Lehaunstown, Cabinteely. Photo:
A room full of bunk beds at The Pines, Lehaunstown. Photo:

Saurya Cherfi

Dozens of occupants, who are unlawfully being rented accommodation in an “unauthorised hostel,” will have to leave the premises by next Wednesday following a court order.

Judge Jaqueline Linnane heard The Pines, Lehaunstown, Cabinteely, where South Americans and eastern Europeans are currently living in dangerous, unhealthy and cramped conditions, was being rented by its owner, Richard Stanley, to a Christian Carter.

Barrister Michael Binchy, for Mr Stanley, said his client was an elderly man in his 80s and in poor health. 

Mr Stanley had rented the property to Mr Carter, with addresses at Dunedin Drive, Monkstown, Co Dublin and at Grove Park, Rathmines, Dublin, and had been unaware of the situation.

Counsel said Mr Stanley was consenting to orders sought by Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council restraining the continued use of the house as a multi-occupancy dormitory property.

The court heard that a son of Mr Stanley, who lives in the UK, had arranged for the tenancy agreement with Mr Carter, who rented the property for €4,000 per month. 

A room full of bunk beds at The Pines, Lehaunstown. Photo:
A room full of bunk beds at The Pines, Lehaunstown. Photo:

Judge Linnane was told the agreement had not been registered with the Residential Tenancy Board and Mr Carter had been taking up to an extra €1,500 a month out of the property by sub-renting it.

Barrister Liam O’Connell, who appeared with law agent Dorothy Kennedy for the local authority, said Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council was also seeking to join Mr Carter to the proceedings.

Mr O’Connell said Mr Carter had been aware of the proceedings and could be served personally with court documents today as it was believed he was in the Four Court complex in relation to another matter.

Mr Binchy said Mr Carter had stated in an email he would empty the premises by March 1st next.  Mr Stanley and Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council had concerns about the welfare of the residents and thought the date was too far away.

Mr O’Connell told Judge Linnane that the residents were aware of the proceedings “coming down the track” and of various inspections of the premises by the local authority.  The court heard they expected they would have to vacate the premises.

Last Monday, when the matter first came before the court, counsel had said that the overcrowded private dwelling was considered a fire and health risk.

“It has come to the council’s notice that the three-storey dwelling is being used as other than a private dwelling with up to 17 individuals in one room and about 36 people housed in the basement,” Mr O’Connell told the court.

Aonghus O Neill, a planning inspector with the local authority, stated in a sworn document that the Lehaunstown house, on four levels, was registered at the Land Registry in the name of Richard Stanley as owner.  It comprised a basement with two rooms, a ground floor, first floor and attic level.

Mr O’Connell told Judge Linnane that the County Council had become aware of reports that up to 70 people were being accommodated in the house and for health and safety reasons had carried out an inspection.

He said Mr O’Neill and another council inspector, Aidan Shannon, found that almost every room they could obtain access to had been filled with either double-beds or bunk beds.

Loose electrical cord providing power to a washing machine and two tumble dryers at the top of a stairs leading to the basement had to be avoided.  In a boiler room there were no smoke or heat detectors and flammable materials were scattered about the room.

One room in the basement contained 11 bunk beds and a second room contained five bunk beds and two double beds.  There were electrical extension cables across the floor. Each of the beds appeared to have been recently slept in.

They had found a communal dining room and a living room which had been turned into dormitories.  Three rooms on the first floor had been locked shut.

Mr O’Connell said the use of the property had changed from that of a private dwelling to one involving the provision of accommodation to paying customers in the course of commercial activity whereby occupants were accommodated in large communal dormitories.

The local authority sought orders to immediately end the use of thes property “as what can only be described as an unauthorised hostel.”

The court heard that Mr Stanley will file a replying affidavit.

Today Judge Linnane joined Mr Carter as a respondent to the proceedings and granted the local authority an order to cease unauthorised development at the property by midday Wednesday 1 February.

The judge ordered that court documents be served on Mr Carter at his two addresses and also on the occupants at the Lehaunstown house. 

She adjourned the matter to next Thursday.

Online Editors

Promoted Links

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Promoted Links

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News