Man who had murder conviction quashed is found guilty in retrial
A DUBLIN man whose murder conviction was quashed by the Court of Criminal Appeal has been found guilty of the offence for the second time.
Bryan Ryan (29), of Ard Caher, Louisburgh, Co. Mayo, but who is originally from Blanchardstown, had pleaded not guilty to murdering Ian Tobin (25) at Fortlawn Park, Blanchardstown, on May 27, 2007.
But the Central Criminal Court jury returned a 10-2 majority verdict of guilty after 6 hours and 27 minutes of deliberation.
Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy handed down the mandatory life sentence and backdated it to March 21, 2010 for time spent in custody.
Mr Justice McCarthy thanked the jury before excusing them from further service for a period of 10 years.
Mr Tobin was shot through a door at a house in Blanchardstown but the court heard his brother was the intended victim of the attack.
The State claimed that Ryan drove the gunman on a motorbike to the killing in Fortlawn Park on the morning in question and the case was one of joint enterprise.
In December 2008 Ryan received a life sentence from Mr Justice Barry White after a jury found him guilty of the murder but the Court of Criminal Appeal overturned the conviction in 2011.
The appeal court ruled that his conviction was unsafe because Mr Justice White failed to properly warn the jury about evidence given by a key prosecution witness - Kevin Whelan - who is in the Witness Protection Programme.
Ryan appealed against his conviction on grounds including that the trial judge had failed to give the jury proper warnings concerning the protected witnesss evidence, in particular as regards the corroboration (independent testimony that tends to show that the crime was committed and was committed by the accused person) of such evidence.
It was also argued the judge further erred by refusing to compel the prosecution to inform the defence of all arrangements and benefits given to the witness in the protection programme.
Mr Tobin was killed at 5.15am on May 27, 2007, but the court heard his brother Blake was the intended target.
The court heard that both the gunman and Ryan abandoned the bike and set it on fire a short distance from the scene of the shooting.
Ryan told Mr Whelan (28), that Blake Tobin was going to be killed by the accuseds girlfriends father Michael Murray, who is now deceased.
Mr Whelan told the court he received a call from Ryan saying Blake Tobin was "getting it".
He gave evidence that two years earlier there was a fistfight between Ryan and Blake Tobin, and that Mr Murray tried to stab Blake Tobin.
The court heard Mr Murray had since been shot dead in March 2009 and he had previously been the victim of another shooting in the autumn of 2008 but survived that attack.
In an interview with gardai on June 21, 2007, Ryan admitted to his involvement in the fatal shooting but said he did not know there was any gun and had believed the person who carried out the shooting was only going to frighten somebody.
Taking to the stand in his own defence, Ryan told his counsel that he admitted to being involved in the fatal shooting because he had been bullied in to making a false confession by detectives.
Ryan denied he made the statement because he knew Mr Whelan had made a statement implicating him in the offence and the cat was out of the bag.
Detective Sergeant Michael Kennedy told Mr Tom O Connell SC prosecuting that Ian Tobin was not involved in criminality.
He said he lived with his partner Sara Murphy and two children and was due to be married in August 2007.