Monday 16 September 2019

Judge orders woman (90s) must be kept in hospital

Stock image
Stock image

Aodhan O Faolain and Ray Managh

A judge has made orders preventing an elderly and very ill woman being removed from the hospital where she is a patient, despite a daughter's wishes.

The court heard any attempt to move her could be very painful.

It was possible a move could result in her death on a trolley in a hospital emergency room while waiting to be admitted to another hospital, or in the back of an ambulance, the court heard.

The woman, who cannot be identified for legal reasons, is in her 90s and her doctors say the best thing to do for her is giving her palliative care.

She has several serious illnesses and conditions including dementia. Various infections had been treated with antibiotics.

The patient is also non-verbal and immobile, of unsound mind and incapable of managing her own affairs.

Those treating her say it is no longer ethical to continue to give her antibiotics, because her veins were collapsing and she was unable to have antibiotics administered to her without causing her pain, and she cannot swallow properly.

While most of the woman's children agree with the medical advice that she should get palliative care, one of the woman's children, who has been her primary carer, disagrees with that assessment.

David Leahy BL for the hospital said that the daughter told doctors that she wants her mother to continue to receive antibiotics and has threatened to move her to another hospital.

Counsel said the hospital was extremely concerned about such a move. The woman's doctors say that even if she were to continue to get antibiotics, she would be unlikely to survive more than two months.

She was already receiving morphine to ease her pain, and doctors wanted to increase her dosage.

The case came before Ms Justice Carmel Stewart, who said it was "a very sad case".

After hearing evidence from a consultant doctor who had been treating the woman, the judge said she was satisfied to grant the hospital various orders allowing it to treat the woman.

The judge also granted the hospital an order preventing the woman's removal from the hospital.

Should this occur, the court further made an order directing gardaí to assist in bringing the woman back to the hospital.

The court also said it would permit the woman to be transferred to a hospice if doctors thought that was in the woman's best interest, and noted that the woman's other children were in agreement with such a proposal.

Ms Justice Stewart also formally opened an inquiry as to whether the woman should be made a ward of court.

Irish Independent

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News