| 12.3°C Dublin

Gemma O'Doherty compares coronavirus restrictions to living 'in Nazi Germany' during High Court submission

Close

Gemma O’Doherty and John Waters leaving the High Court in Dublin.
Photo by Steve Humphreys
5th May 2020

Gemma O’Doherty and John Waters leaving the High Court in Dublin. Photo by Steve Humphreys 5th May 2020

Gemma O’Doherty and John Waters leaving the High Court in Dublin. Photo by Steve Humphreys 5th May 2020

John Waters and Gemma O'Doherty have told the High Court that laws introduced due to the Covid-19 pandemic are "unprecedented" and amount to an "effective suspension" of every citizen's constitutional rights.

In judicial review proceedings against the State and the Minister for Health they seek to have various pieces of recently enacted legislation, which they say are unconstitutional and flawed, quashed by a judge of the High Court

The High Court has directed that their application for permission to bring their challenge be heard in the presence of the respondents.

Both the state and lawyers representing the Dail, Seanad and the Ceann Comhairle which are notice parties to the proceedings claim the court should not allow them bring the challenge and that the case should be dismissed.

The preliminary application to determine if permission should be granted is being heard by Mr Justice Charles Meenan.

In their submissions, they said the laws that had been introduced, and the manner in which they were enacted, are repugnant to several articles of the constitution including rights to travel, bodily integrity and the family.

Mr Waters said that the issues that he and Ms O'Doherty were raising were hugely important for all citizens.

The laws he said keep people in their homes, and have resulted in the closure of parks and beaches, he said.

Close

Gemma O’Doherty and John Waters address supporters outside the High Court in Dublin.
Photo by Steve Humphreys
5th May 2020

Gemma O’Doherty and John Waters address supporters outside the High Court in Dublin. Photo by Steve Humphreys 5th May 2020

Gemma O’Doherty and John Waters address supporters outside the High Court in Dublin. Photo by Steve Humphreys 5th May 2020

Mr Waters said he agreed with comments by former British Supreme Court judge Lord Sumption who described the restrictions in place in the UK, which Mr Waters said are similar to the ones in Ireland, as being worse that than what was imposed in the UK during World War Two.

Referring to the economic impact of the restrictions he said he feared that the country could find itself back in the place it was in 1929 when the Wall Street Crash sent the would into an economic depression.

Daily Digest Newsletter

Get ahead of the day with the morning headlines at 7.30am and Fionnán Sheahan's exclusive take on the day's news every afternoon, with our free daily newsletter.

This field is required

Mr Waters also told the court that they do not accept the accuracy of the number of deaths in the State attributable to Covid-19, due to the manner in which such deaths are being officially recorded.

Ms O'Doherty said the the laws had given powers allowing the Gardai to harass people when they go out and about and have kept citizens under mass house arrest.

During her submissions to the court she compared the restrictions to like living "in Nazi Germany" where people were required to carry papers with them at all times.

In their action Ms O'Doherty and Mr Waters have challenged legislation including the 2020 Health Preservation and Protection and Other Emergency Measures in the Public Interest Act, the 2020 Emergency Measures in the Public

Interest Act Covid-19 Act, The 1947 Health Act (Affected Areas) Order.

Their proceedings are also aimed at striking down temporary restriction regulations brought due to Covid-19 under the 1947 Health Act.

The state represented by Patrick McCann SC, appearing with Gerard Meehan Bl, opposes the application for leave, and says that the claims are not arguable.

The Dail, the Seanad and the Ceann Comhairle, which have been added as notice parties to the action because part of the challenge concerns how the laws were enacted and represented by Francis Kieran Bl, is also opposed to leave being granted.

As was the case when the matter was before the court last week, there was tight security and a large Garda presence around the Four Courts Complex.

Supporters of Mr Waters and Ms O'Doherty remained outside barriers erected by the Gardai close to the courtroom where the case is being heard.

Only a limited number of persons were allowed into the court due to social distancing conditions imposed by the Courts Service.

The hearing continues on Wednesday.


Most Watched





Privacy