Wednesday 21 March 2018

Gardai locked mum in bathroom while beating her son, court told

Victim Owen Gaffney. Photo: Collins
Victim Owen Gaffney. Photo: Collins
Fidelma Gaffney. Photo: Collins
Garda Claire Delaney. Photo: Collins
Garda Alan Conlon. Photo: Collins
Garda Eoin Murtagh. Photo: Collins
Garda Sean O'Leary. Photo: Collins

Sarah Stack

A GARDA grabbed a woman by the throat and locked her in a bathroom while his colleagues beat her teenage son as he slept in bed, a court heard yesterday.

Officers Alan Conlon (29), Claire Delaney (25), Eoin Murtagh (30) and Sean O'Leary (34) attacked Owen Gaffney with a baton before he was punched and kicked, it was claimed.

All four are charged with assault causing harm, forcible entry and trespass at the Gaffney family home in inner-city Dublin on February 17, 2008.

Three of the accused, Garda Conlon, Garda Delaney and Garda Murtagh, are also accused of the false imprisonment of Mr Gaffney's mother Fidelma in a bathroom during the ordeal.

The gardai, who are suspended from the force, deny the charges.

Opening the trial for the prosecution, Tom O'Connell told Dublin Circuit Criminal Court the incident appeared to be a pre-arranged plan to give the then 17-year-old a beating.

"This case is about guards behaving unlawfully for reasons which will become apparent in the course of the trial," he told the jury.

Mr O'Connell said there had been a history of conflict between a number of gardai and Mr Gaffney, who lived at the Basin Street flats near St James's Hospital.

The officers, who were travelling in two separate squad cars, are said to have met earlier on the Sunday afternoon when they allegedly made a concerted plan to assault Mr Gaffney. About nine are believed to have been in the vicinity of his home during the incident.

The state barrister said witnesses, including other gardai on duty, will describe how Garda Delaney waved a piece of paper in Mrs Gaffney's face pretending it was a warrant as the others went upstairs unlawfully.


Mrs Gaffney (41) told investigators that she followed them to her son's bedroom where she saw Garda O'Leary lift the duvet and hit Mr Gaffney over the head with a baton as another garda kicked him.

She claimed an officer pulled her arms behind her back, grabbed her by the throat and forced her into the bathroom. Several gardai then took turns to hold the door handle up to keep her inside for about five minutes, the court heard.

"Another person in the house at the time could hear Mrs Gaffney screaming upstairs and saw guards holding the bathroom door," Mr O'Connell said.

A family friend who had rung Mrs Gaffney just before she opened her front door to officers recorded the incident on his mobile phone, he added.

Three of the gardai, Delaney, Murtagh and O'Leary, were stationed in Kilmainham at the time. Garda Conlon was stationed at Kevin Street.

It is claimed that once they were back in their garda cars, Garda O'Leary asked for an antiseptic wipe to clean blood from his baton while Garda Murtagh wiped blood off his knuckles.

The victim was taken to hospital and treated for a cut lip, a bruise on the top of his head, a swollen nose, a laceration to his right upper arm, and bruising on his upper body.

Mrs Gaffney lodged a complaint with Detective Sergeant Colette Wheeler, a duty officer in Kilmainham, who revealed there were no planned searches in the Basin Street area that afternoon.

The case was passed to the Garda Ombudsman and a major investigation launched.

Mr O'Connell claimed forensic tests will reveal a one-in-a-million chance that a mix of blood found on the handle of a baton did not belong to Mr Gaffney and Garda Murtagh.

He warned the jury that, while the accused were innocent until proven guilty, members of An Garda Siochana were not beyond the law.

"If they behave unlawfully and if they behave in a manner which is not justified, then of course they are subject to the law like any other citizen," he added.

The trial before Judge Des- mond Hogan is expected to last two weeks.

Irish Independent

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox every morning.

Editor's Choice

Also in Irish News