Kids’ TV fails to properly represent LGBT community or working class – report
PAW Patrol and My Little Pony have been criticised.
More action is needed to “shape the perceptions” of children watching non-inclusive TV, according to a report.
The study, titled Is TV Making Your Child Prejudiced?, has argued that preschool entertainment is guilty of poor minority representation and the use of stereotypes.
PAW Patrol was criticised over gender balance, while My Little Pony was found lacking in its portrayal of class distinctions.
The report claimed that children’s cartoons and TV shows fail to adequately represent black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) characters, the LGBT community, disabled people, women, and the working class.
The study, by children’s app company Hopster, said progress has been made but argued that “more work needs to be done to help positively shape the perceptions of our youngest generation”.
Nick Walters, founder of Hopster, said: “Many shows aimed at preschoolers are entertaining and educational, but it’s clear from our research that stereotypes still creep in.
“It’s so important that kids from all types of families see themselves represented in the shows they watch.”
The report examined 50 popular children’s TV shows for their inclusivity, and the negative or positive nature of on-screen representation.
'Working-class’ goat characters are given strong Southern US accents
It has been claimed that only 9% of material viewed showed working-class families, with mansions and palaces commonplace in children’s TV.
The report said this lapse is “demonstrated in My Little Pony, where the unintelligent, ‘working-class’ goat characters are given strong Southern US accents”.
Concerns were also raised that just 16% of content studied displayed disability, and often did so negatively. Only 7% of studied content reference an LGBT character.
The Go Jetters, cited as a good example in the study, was praised for “featuring a male unicorn as a lead character”, and an episode where male characters lean in to kiss each other.
Hopster said: “White characters dominated the content selected for this study.”
Its study found that BAME representation was also tokenistic, such as in Horrid Henry, and that shows missed the opportunity to portray diverse faiths on screen. Only six shows of 50 had BAME lead characters.
There are only two female dogs alongside the five male leads
Hopster added that, through visuals or voice-overs, “non-real life characters can still achieve BAME representation”, with Teletubbies cited as a good example.
The report claimed that a third of content viewed perpetuated gender stereotypes, showing “boys who fight” and “girls who are image-orientated”.
It cited PAW Patrol, “where, although all equally capable, there are only two female dogs alongside the five male leads”.
Child and educational psychologist Laverne Antrobus said: “Preschoolers as the next generation need to view programmes that invite them into a world where the rich layers of difference are celebrated and crucially seen within their favourite programmes.
We don't want to nurture a new generation of binge watchers (like mum & dad!) - so after 3 episodes of the same show, we'll now suggest your little one tries something else instead. #NoMoreBingeWatching 🚫🎉 pic.twitter.com/mMBzQbknfW— Hopster (@hopsterTV) July 13, 2019
“Parents need to be mindful of the content their kids are watching, as seeing themselves and others reflected on screen will nurture their sense of a society in which everyone is represented and can feel they belong.”
Hopster’s report also cautioned against negative portrayals of “nerds” as wearing glasses, and single mothers as incapable, such as in Fireman Sam.
Content on streaming services and YouTube was found to be worse at representation than more traditional media.
Parents have been urged to be aware of what messages their children are receiving, and warned that dated content such as Tom And Jerry – with African American character Mammy Two Shoes – is still available.
Warren Kirwan, of disability equality charity Scope, said: “Children’s TV has the potential to shape the attitudes of the next generation, which is why it’s so important that it gets diversity right.
“It’s particularly worrying that when children’s programmes do show disability, it’s often in a negative way.
“We hope children’s TV producers will explore disability in a positive way, and create more diverse characters which reflect the lives of disabled children.”
Hopster is an app designed for the under-sixes, which aims to educate and entertain.