Entertainment Book Reviews

Monday 16 September 2019

Manson family murders: New book claims CIA figures linked to mastermind behind 1969 killings

Non-fiction:  Chaos: Charles Manson, the CIA, and the Secret History of the Sixties

Tom O'Neill

William Heinemann, hardback, 528 pages, €28

Missed opportunities: Manson and members of his group were arrested but never charged before the 1969 murders
Missed opportunities: Manson and members of his group were arrested but never charged before the 1969 murders
Chaos: Charles Manson, the CIA, and the Secret History of the Sixties

Jancee Dunn

On a sweltering morning 50 years ago this month, a maid arriving at a secluded Beverly Hills estate found a scene of horror: five dead bodies strewn about the isolated house, among them pregnant actress Sharon Tate, who had rented the property with her husband, the director Roman Polanski. Blood was everywhere; it had even been used to scrawl the word "pig" on the front door. The next night, grocery-shop owner Leno LaBianca and his wife were killed in a similar fashion, again bloody messages were left on the walls, including a misspelled 'Healter Skelter'. America was terrified.

Nearly four months passed before the killers, a strange group of flower children who had lived at an abandoned movie ranch under the spell of leader Charles Manson, were arrested. The murders had been bizarre, but the alleged motive argued by prosecutor Vincent Bugliosi in court and expanded in his bestselling book Helter Skelter was even more so: an ex-convict who claimed to be both Jesus Christ and Satan, whose mainly middle-class followers had seemingly turned into drug-addicted zombies and killed to bring about the end of the world.

Please log in or register with Independent.ie for free access to this article.

Log In

The Bible and a Beatles' song, Manson held, both predicted a race war, during which he and his so-called Family would live in a bottomless pit in the desert before emerging to rule the world. But as journalist Tom O'Neill shows in his new book, Chaos, Bugliosi's flamboyant theory, rather than revealing the truth, merely concealed a tangled mass of contradictory motives in this most infamous of crimes.

Conspiracy theories have ringed the Manson case since 1969, with allegations of drug deals gone bad, CIA-sponsored mind-control experiments, celebrity sex tapes and revenge after producer Terry Melcher (Doris Day's son, who had previously lived at the Tate house) did not give the cult leader a recording contract. It's a confusing, often conflicting journey down the rabbit hole.

O'Neill attempts to burrow deep beneath the surface of the murders. This isn't so much a history of the crimes as it is a chronicle of his investigation. It started as a feature for now-defunct US magazine Premiere in 1999; it took O'Neill US 20 years of intensive research, and hundreds of interviews, to bring his story to its ambiguous conclusion. Along the way, he found legal misconduct, suppressed information and loose connections suggesting a much darker picture of what led to the 1969 murders.

It's probably no accident that this book appeared after Bugliosi's death in 2015: O'Neill uncovered troubling indications that the prosecutor may have withheld evidence from the defence and perhaps encouraged perjury, strong-armed witnesses and lied during the trials, in an effort to strengthen his 'Helter Skelter' motive. "Much of what we accept as fact," O'Neill writes of the case, "is fiction."

Some of O'Neill's discoveries are stunning, especially when he's discussing the inexplicable leniency shown by law-enforcement officials and by Manson's parole officer. Both before and after the August murders, Manson and several members of his group were arrested for various crimes but never charged. O'Neill speculates that this may have led to some sort of later cover-up, meant to conceal the fact that inaction may have resulted in additional deaths.

There's also a previously unknown telephone call that may have set the Tate-LaBianca murders into motion. In late July 1969, Manson associate Bobby Beausoleil and two female 'Family' members killed musician Gary Hinman. Hoping to cast blame on the Black Panthers, they'd left the message 'Political Piggy' scrawled on a wall in Hinman's blood.

On August 8, Beausoleil made a call to his fellow cultists while in custody. He'd been arrested for Hinman's murder and needed "help," adding: "Leave a sign." Manson repeated this admonition to the foursome he sent to the Tate house just hours later; the "sign" took the form of "pig" written in Tate's blood on the front door, presumably in the hope that police would think Hinman's killer was still on the loose.

O'Neill confirmed the call with two former detectives who, thinking (rightly) that they'd linked the Hinman and Tate murders, found their inquiries quashed by superiors. Other details, though, are less convincing, including claims, decades after the fact, that a shadowy figure (and possible CIA agent) knew of the Tate murders before the maid discovered the bodies.

Read more: The Manson Murders: The night that Hollywood slid into the darkness

O'Neill worries that his explorations make him "one of 'those people': an obsessive, a conspiracy theorist, a lunatic." Indeed, the last third of the book tosses in shadowy figures and their possible connections to Manson. There's the CIA, hoping to use unwitting hippies in San Francisco to study the effects of LSD; the director of the Haight-Ashbury Free Medical Clinic, investigating whether amphetamines led to violence; and even suggestions that a man tied to Lee Harvey Oswald assassin Jack Ruby may have crossed paths with Manson and used him in some kind of unofficial mind-control investigation. It's all intriguing, perhaps even suggestive of some dark motive behind the murders, but O'Neill is unable to make the connections or even reach any firm conclusions: "I didn't have a smoking gun," the author admits.

There's plenty of new information that makes Chaos a worthwhile addition to the canon of Manson literature, even if it ends without a unified theory of the crimes and their motivations. "My goal isn't to say what did happen," O'Neill explains, "it's to prove that the official story didn't." In that he succeeds. 'Helter Skelter' may no longer convince as a motive, but, with Manson's death in 2017, it is unlikely that history will ever penetrate the remaining mysteries surrounding the grisly events that summer of 1969.

© Washington Post

Read more: How the Manson murders killed off old Hollywood

Indo Review

Editors Choice

Also in Entertainment

Back to top