| 7.5°C Dublin

Volatility makes Tesla a bumpy ride for institutions

Company shares have seen 21 daily moves of at least 5pc to the upside or downside this year

Close

Tesla shares jumped as much as 4.3pc in New York. Photo: Aly Song/Reuters

Tesla shares jumped as much as 4.3pc in New York. Photo: Aly Song/Reuters

Tesla shares jumped as much as 4.3pc in New York. Photo: Aly Song/Reuters

Big investors love many things about Tesla. Volatility isn't one of them.

Despite a trillion-dollar valuation, pole position in the electric-vehicle business and entry to the S&P 500, the world's sixth-largest listed company is subject to greater swings than any other US megacap technology stock, with 21 daily moves of at least 5pc to the upside or downside this year.

"It is not a name we would recommend to our clients," said Edmund Shing, BNP Paribas Wealth's chief investment officer, citing volatility brought about by high levels of interest among retail investors.

Tuesday’s sharp about-turn in the stock, without any fundamental catalyst, highlights the unpredictability. Tesla shares jumped as much as 4.3pc in New York, despite a Monday post-market disclosure that chief executive officer Elon Musk had exercised options and sold more shares. The string of sales by Mr Musk had caused the stock to fall about 15pc since his Twitter poll asking followers whether he should sell shares, wiping nearly $200bn (€176.5bn) off the company's market value.

Tesla's volatility has frequently spilled over to other EV stocks, making it a hallmark for the group. The most recent examples are a five-day rally in newly public Rivian Automotive, taking its valuation past Volkswagen AG on Tuesday, and a 19pc surge in Lucid Group's shares after the company said it remained confident in its ability to produce 20,000 units in 2022.

Still, it's hard to completely ignore a stock that's up 47pc in 2021, after surging more than eightfold the year before.

Mr Shing recommends gaining exposure through exchange traded funds or other passive investing methods.

"We prefer our clients to take indirect exposure that way, so as to benefit from some diversification and offset to volatility that other stocks can provide."

Indeed that's been the general narrative in the latest regulatory filings from institutional investors. Hedge funds have increased the amount of exchange-traded funds in their portfolios in the third quarter, while decreasing their exposure to single stocks, according to 13F filings.

Tesla's addition to the S&P 500 late last year didn't go down too well with institutional holders averse to volatility. They included Mark Stoeckle, chief executive officer and senior portfolio manager at Adams Funds.

Business Newsletter

Read the leading stories from the world of business.

This field is required

With a 2pc-plus weighting on the US benchmark index, Mr Stoeckle had to look beyond Tesla's frequent wild swings and buy in, he said by phone.

At the other end of the spectrum, amateur traders have been gobbling up Tesla stock through call options – used to position for gains in stocks.

According to Goldman Sachs Group, Tesla and Amazon.com represented more than half of the single-stock options traded in early November.

But Mr Musk's near $8bn stock sale might act as a deterrent, at least for now.


Privacy