Monday 21 October 2019



Apple Watch Series 4
Apple Watch Series 4
Samsung Gear S3 Frontier
Fitbit Charge 3
Garmin Fenix 5
Adrian Weckler

Adrian Weckler

Those looking for a last-minute Christmas gift might consider a smartwatch. But which one? Apple? Samsung? Or a health device such as a Garmin or a Fitbit? Adrian Weckler has tested four of the best on the market.

Apple Watch Series 4

Price: from €439 (40mm) and €469 (44mm)

The current Series 4 improved on last year's Series 3 (which is still on sale from €279) mainly via the display screen, which is considerably larger than the previous three generations, even though the watch itself is around the same size.

This is because Apple has thinned out the bezels, the non-active parts at the side of the display. That means 44mm instead of 42mm, or 40mm instead of 38mm.

One of the most talked-about features of the new watch is the built-in ECG function, an ability to monitor your heart's health.

Alas, even though it's technically built in to the device, it's not available to us in Europe yet, for regulatory reasons. Apple sells two variants of its watch, a GPS and GPS+Cellular version. In the US, UK and other countries, the cellular version works with your phone contract, allowing you to make or take calls, send SMS messages or access online services on your watch while you're out and about and your iPhone is at home. So far, no Irish operator has done a deal with Apple to make this happen here. And no, it won't work if you buy one in the UK (or the US) and use it over here, partly because the cellular function on the Apple Watch doesn't roam (at all).

When it comes to fitness, the Series 4 builds on the big leap it took for the previous Series 3 model. It's still waterproof and there's a ton of information that you get for running, walking, swimming or doing intense workouts. It works really well with some of the most common sports apps, such as Runkeeper, Strava, Runtastic and Map My Run. It's not as good for sleep tracking, if that's important to you.

Battery life is a good deal beyond what you got with the first model in 2015 (one day) but is still only solidly two days. (I sometimes get close to three full days on it, if I don't use it for music or messaging.)

Samsung Gear S3 Frontier

Price: €289

This is a circular smartwatch with a clever way of navigating through features. The front-facing rim rotates to control certain things. It's a very intuitive way of getting around the watch and is unique to Samsung when it comes to the main smartwatch brands.

Another relative advantage it has over Apple's watch is an always-on display, meaning you don't have lift the watch face toward you to spark it to life. This is a small thing but not having an always-on display irritates some people.

The Gear S3 doesn't run as many apps as Apple's watch. This may be a disadvantage to some, but if you're mainly interested in sport and fitness, you might not care. For running, its native functionality absolutely does the job, integrating nicely with Samsung's S Health platform. With GPS and an accelerometer, it's very solid when it comes to tracking.

Fitbit Charge 3

Price: €139

If a slim, fitness-friendly device with a reasonable amount of basic smart functions is your aim, Fitbit's Charge 3 is excellent.

While its core functionality is measuring steps and sleep, with full reporting and the ability to synchronise with a number of common running of fitness apps, this also has social and SMS messaging alerts.

But it doesn't go over the top on it, as it's primarily a text-based device.

Because it's a relatively slim, monotone device, it has a decent battery life of around five to six days.

There's also a premium version of the gadget (which costs €20 extra) that now supports Fitbit Pay (though that's only useful if you happen to bank with KBC or AIB).

So with this, you'll have your basics covered and a reasonable amount of extras at a price that hopefully won't kill your budget.

Garmin Fenix 5

Price: €699

If sport and fitness is your avowed aim, you'll get by reasonably well with an Apple Watch, Samsung Gear or Fitbit. But if you really want to max out on metrics and functionality, you'll probably want to look at Garmin.

The Fenix 5 Plus tracks just about any kind of sport you can think of. It even does a good job of assessing off-kilter activities such as yoga, should you decide to partake.

But it's especially good for running. The data it feeds back is unparalleled - everything from pace and distance and elevation to things like cadence. It has a metric called Performance Condition, which gives you an overall indication of whether your body is capable of the training routine you're setting out for it. There's also a 'Training Status' data set that assesses how you've done (relative to all your other data metrics) over the last seven days. As for keeping score of your workouts, this synchronises with some major apps such as Strava.

You can try others (Fitbit has one called the Ionic that costs quite a bit less and does a reasonably good job). But of all the premium, dedicated sports and fitness smart watches out there, this is probably the king.

Indo Business

Also in Business