Sunday 8 December 2019

Save €300 a year by changing mobile phone provider

Research shows that just one in seven of us bothered to ditch our mobile-phone provider for another one. Stock image
Research shows that just one in seven of us bothered to ditch our mobile-phone provider for another one. Stock image
Charlie Weston

Charlie Weston

THERE are more mobile phones in Ireland than there are people. There are just short of five million of the devices. We love to talk and we are big users of data on our phones, but surprisingly we are not keen on changing networks.

This is despite the fact that you can make savings of €300 a year from ending a contract with an expensive mobile phone operator and opting for a better-value phone contract. Research shows that just one in seven of us bothered to ditch our mobile-phone provider for another one.

That is up slightly on previous years, but it compares with close to a third of people who will change motor insurer in a given year.

According to the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission - the State body set up to enforce consumer protection - the savings from switching mobile phone operator are among the highest of all household bills.

Loyalty is for losers

Loyalty is often the reason we resist seeking a better deal.

But in the case of mobile phones, the sheer number of different plans and their complexity plays a big role in stopping us getting a better deal.

There are now three dominant mobile phone operators in this market - Vodafone, Three and Eir (Meteor/eMobile). Smaller operators include Tesco and LycaMobile. Recently, Dixons Carphone launched iD Mobile, and Virgin Mobile also entered the market.

Questions to ask

When considering switching plans, you need to be clear about what kind of mobile phone user you are.

Ask yourself if you spend time talking on the phone or do you prefer sending text messages?

If you send a lot of messages, do you send traditional texts or do you use tools like WhatsApp, which eats into your data allowance?

How much data do you consume a month? The answer will typically be over 1GB if you consume a lot of online video and streaming music.

Once you understand these factors, it is a case of shopping around for the most suitable plan for your needs. Do not be drawn to spend extra on unlimited plans if you are not a heavy user. Who needs unlimited texts if you never use them?

Remember that it is possible to spend €25 a month with one provider and €75 with another for the exact same usage.

Plan guide

The Killbiller App will audit your usage and recommend a plan for you based on your actual usage. Low users could be spending as little as €12 per month, while even heavy users should not be spending more than €25 per month on a SIM-only plan.

Bart Lehane of makes the following points:

  • new smartphones are only offering incremental advances these days. In many cases, people who are coming out of a 18/24 month contract will have perfectly good smartphones;
  • by keeping their current smartphone, mobile subscribers can avoid expensive and lengthy contracts and instead go with the lower cost and freedom of SIM-only plans or pre-pay plans;
  • data should be the single biggest factor when it comes to deciding on a new plan. Most plans now come with unlimited texts and generous call amounts as networks realise we are becoming more data focused;
  • data rates are increasing rapidly, so the amount of data you use right now will increase over the next year. The average smartphone user uses 3.4GB of data per month (almost a 70pc increase on last year). If you are entering into an 18 or 24-month contract, ensure you add some buffer for data. Go for 10GB per month if you can afford it.

How to fix it

You can move from one operator to another without any fuss. You can even keep your full mobile number, what people in the mobile phone business call number portability.

The main thing to be aware of when switching from one service provider to another is whether any minimum contract term applies to your existing contract, according to the telecoms regulator ComReg. If you are still in contract, you will be charged cancellation fees by your existing provider if you leave before that period is up.

If you have upgraded or changed to a new package with your existing provider, this can result in an extension of the minimum contract term. You should also check your existing terms and conditions to see if you are required to give 30 days' notice before leaving the current service provider.

If there are no minimum term/notice period issues, then all you have to do to switch is to contact the new provider and advise them you wish to sign up to their service.

Good plans

Here are some plan recommendations from

  • people who want a phone (bill pay with phone): Tesco mobile is rapidly gaining market share in Ireland with its brand of decent smartphones and cheap plans. Its €30 bill pay plan comes with 15 GB data, 500 minutes and 500 texts and includes a number of good quality smartphones for free or low cost.
  • people who can go SIM-only (and not get a phone): some new discounts just arrived on to the market this month. iD has 30pc off bill pay and SIM-only plans for six months. Lehane advised mobile users to go for its 20GB, 100 minutes, 100 texts plan which normally costs €20 a month but, with the discount, will cost €14 a month for six months. If you are SIM free, you can leave after the six months to another network or stay on and pay €20 a month.

Meteor currently has €5 off its SIM-only plans for six months. Lehane says avoid the Lite plan with only 1GB data, but the Regular Extra plan has 10GB data, 400 minutes and unlimited texts for €20 a month.

Prepay plans

Again, Tesco mobile has a great deal with a €15 top-up giving 10GB data and unlimited calls. You can use your remaining credit to get an unlimited text add-on meaning you get 10GB data, unlimited calls and unlimited texts for €15.


How to switch phone providers

Step 1 Choose a mobile operator. Compare the price plans on offer from the main mobile operators on the market at This site is run by the regulator, ComReg. You will have to dig out a bill and enter into the website how many texts you send in a month, the amount of data you use, and your calls to landlines and to mobiles. Alternatively, you can download the free app from, which burrows into your phone and assesses your usage. It then tells you what you would spend on all available plans, with your own network or another operator.

Step 2 Contact your new operator and provide your details. You can either phone them, go online or call into their retail outlets. When you move to a new operator, you can keep your old number if you want. STEP 3 Switch. Your new mobile operator should complete the process for you within a few hours. So, if you are unhappy with the service provided by your mobile operator or if you feel you are paying too much, consider switching today.

Potential saving: €300

Total time: 30 mins


Read more:

Irish Independent

Also in Business