Farm Ireland

Saturday 24 March 2018

Donkey welfare crisis at breaking point

Indiscriminate breeding has seen a sharp rise in the number of donkeys being rescued by animal charities

Sue Paling forking fodder last January at the Sathya Sai Sanctuary for rescued donkeys on the slopes of the Bricklieve Mountains, Co Sligo.
Sue Paling forking fodder last January at the Sathya Sai Sanctuary for rescued donkeys on the slopes of the Bricklieve Mountains, Co Sligo.
Donkeys pictured in Co Leitrim. Photo: Frank McGrath.
Fair City actor Geoff Minogue visiting The Donkey Sanctuary in Co Cork recently. Donkeys are available for adoption at a cost of just €20 per year. See
Siobhan English

Siobhan English

Experts are concerned that more and more farmers are seeing donkeys as a low-cost means of reaching the minimum stocking density required for the Areas of Natural Constraint Scheme.

A careful review of the ANC scheme for farmers, in addition to looking at the castration of young male donkeys, are among a raft of proposals being suggested to tackle the donkey welfare problem in Ireland.

The proposals feature in a lengthy report compiled by UCD which was funded by The Donkey Sanctuary and launched recently by Minister Simon Coveney.

The downturn in Ireland's economy led to a serious equine welfare issue.

Sadly donkeys have not escaped this crisis, with rescue centres across Ireland left to pick up the pieces as these animals, too, become surplus to requirements.

Last year, 388 donkeys were rescued by The Donkey Sanctuary in Co Cork, with dozens more being taken in by the ISPCA and many of the other rescue centres who find themselves full to capacity, particularly over the winter months.

The previous year The Donkey Sanctuary took 299 donkeys into its care and transported a further 291 to its parent organisation in Devon, England.

Up until June of this year it had over 1,500 donkeys in its care on its own farms, in paid livery and in foster homes throughout the country.

Also Read

"And a large percentage of those taken in are not micro-chipped and therefore untraceable, with many of them young uncastrated males," says Dr Joe Collins, who was joined on the research team by Dr Vivienne Duggan and Sarah Finney of UCD and Professor Patrick Wall, chairman of Horse Sport Ireland.

Research has shown that much of the problem lies with the lack of breeding regulations.

There is no requirement here for the licensing of breeding donkeys - stallions or mares - or other controls on the keeping of non-neutered animals.

During the boom years of the early 2000s, there was a demand for novelty items of all kinds and it was generally considered that there was profit in the breeding of donkeys for sale.

Young donkeys, especially fillies, often traded for hundreds of euro each at fairs.

Fast forward a decade and while there is still a limited interest in donkeys - especially for showing - many are selling for nominal fees.

Others are being advertised 'free-to-a-good-home' through the various online market places, or, in far too many cases, being abandoned on waste land.

The cost of castrating the young males far outweighs their value.

In some cases donkeys have even been dumped on farmland, with farmers only discovering the additional animals days later.

Experts raised concerns donkeys may be seen as a low cost method of reaching the minimum stocking rate for ANC, particularly in the absence of requirements and inspections of specific equine welfare inputs such as buildings or shelters.

In order to claim such agricultural subsidies farmers have to demonstrate that the land is being farmed.

This generally means keeping, and demonstrating that they keep, qualifying livestock at a level above an agreed minimum stocking density, which are correctly identified and recorded.

The minimum stocking density, for example, has been fixed at 0.15 Livestock Units (LU) per hectare.

Cattle, sheep, deer, horses and donkeys qualify for use in the calculation of minimum stocking densities at varying LU value eg cattle over two years of age qualified as 1 LU each, the same as a donkeys.

However, subsistence farmers - by definition farming in disadvantaged areas of natural constraint - often find that the farming of cattle or sheep is a marginal or indeed loss-making enterprise. New rules regarding the keeping of horses introduced in 2012 also affected their numbers.

While applicants now have to show that their farm qualifies as an 'equine breeding enterprise' before the keeping of horses as qualifying livestock is permitted, donkeys continue to be eligible without the need to demonstrate any additional requirements.

They simply need to be appropriately registered with identification documentation showing the animals are in the ownership of the given applicant.

In 2011 there were 3,774 DAS applicants who registered 18,447 equines on the scheme. In 2012 there were only 1,469 applicants, who registered 6,768 equines.

The number of donkeys registered by persons not registering any horses for use on DAS/ANC in 2014 was 1,471 (in the care of 405 applicants) from a total of 5,156 equines (2,544 of them donkeys) in the care of 1,280 applicants.

The corresponding figures for the year 2013 were: 1,591 donkeys (from a total of 2,593 donkeys) in the care of 411 donkey-only applicants as a subset of 6,159 equines in the care of 1,436 equine-keeping applicants to DAS.

According to figures published for 2014, there were over 2,500 donkeys registered as Livestock Units (LUs) at a payment value of €1.6 million.

Galway and Mayo accounted for approximately one-third of that total number of both applicants and donkeys, with an average of 3.5 donkeys per applicant.

While DAFM has decided not to change the eligibility criteria for donkeys this year, it is believed that they looking at potentially restricting new donkey applications and/or the registration of new donkeys on existing applications.

There may also be a cap on the number of donkeys an applicant might register for use as Livestock Units (LUs), or otherwise capping the percentage of an applicant's LU requirement that he/she can fill using donkeys.

Animal welfare experts, however, are concerned that this may put an added burden on the animal welfare groups who are already struggling to cope with high numbers of abandoned animals.

These will include adult micro-chipped donkeys currently registered on Area Aid Schemes and as-of-yet unidentified juveniles (especially uncastrated males) with even lower monetary value than their current low market value.

"Each January we worry if new changes will be implemented and what affect it will have on donkey welfare," said Dr Joe Collins said.

"In light of this we now hope to meet with the relevant people to discuss the welfare, and the future of donkeys in Ireland."

Indo Farming