Tuesday 21 October 2014

Family of Dublin doctor 'murdered in case of mistaken identity'

Father is a consultant neurosurgeon at Beaumont Hospital - fears that family killed in 'revenge killing'

Published 13/09/2013 | 12:30

Fire crews at the scene of a house fire at Wood Hill, in the Spinney Hills area of Leicester which claimed the lives of four people
Fire crews at the scene of a house fire at Wood Hill, in the Spinney Hills area of Leicester which claimed the lives of four people
The scene of a house fire at Wood Hill, in the Spinney Hills area
of Leicester which claimed the lives of four people. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Friday September 13, 2013. Police investigating the deaths have said they cannot rule out the blaze being linked to the murder of a man in a nearby street. See PA story FIRE Leicester. Photo credit should read: Phil Barnett/PA Wire
The scene of a house fire at Wood Hill, in the Spinney Hills area of Leicester which claimed the lives of four people
The scene of a house fire at Wood Hill, in the Spinney Hills area of Leicester which claimed the lives of four people
The scene of a house fire at Wood Hill, in the Spinney Hills area of Leicester which claimed the lives of four people

A family murdered in a suspected revenge attack may have been the victims of mistaken identity, a neighbour has said.

Shehnila Taufiq, who was in her 40s, died along with her 19-year-old daughter and sons, aged 17 and 15, when their home was engulfed in flames early today.

Mrs Taufiq's neurosurgeon husband, Mohammad Sattar, is believed to be en route home from Ireland where he works.

The mother and her children, named by the local mosque in Leicester as Zainab, Jamal and Bilal, died in their bedrooms at their terraced house in Wood Hill in the Spinney Hills area of the city several hours after a man was killed in nearby Kent Street.

Police said they could not rule out a link between the two events and said they are investigating whether the fire had been intentionally started as a revenge attack.

But neighbours of the family reacted with disbelief to the idea that they could have been intentionally killed - and claimed they may not have been the intended target.

A middle-aged man, who did not want to be named, said: "I didn't know the family personally but I knew of them and they were a very nice family.

"Most people feel this was meant for somebody else and they got the wrong house.

"The family were very well-educated. He was a brain surgeon in Ireland and he brought his family over here to study Islamic literature.

"The lads were very pious and one of them was memorising the Koran and was on the ninth chapter."

Describing the blaze, the witness said: "I was in bed at about midnight and I heard all the commotion and thought it was drunks or whatever, and then I heard shouting.

"The guy opposite broke the door down but the fire was so intense they couldn't get in.

"They were throwing bricks at the windows at the top of the house to alert them inside but I think it was too late.

"The fire was very intense and you could feel the heat of it across the road.

"The neighbours tried their level best but it was too severe."

Leicestershire Police have not confirmed the identities of the five victims.

The force launched its first murder inquiry shortly after 5.30pm yesterday when a man in his 20s was taken from Kent Street - half a mile away from the scene of the fire - to Leicester Royal Infirmary, where he died.

Less than 24 hours later a second inquiry began when neighbours reported flames shooting out of the first floor of the Taufiq family home at 12.30am.

As police appealed for information, Assistant Chief Constable Roger Bannister said officers were investigating a theory that Mrs Taufiq and her children were killed in revenge for the earlier attack.

He said: "These are obviously both very serious incidents and the investigations are in their very early stages to establish if there are any links between them.

"I can't confirm here and now it is a revenge attack - it may be, it may not be - but lines of inquiry will certainly get to the bottom of that."

Referring to neighbours talking about a "fire-bombing", Mr Bannister added: "Fire-bombing, in my experience, means different things to different people.

"We are working really closely with the fire brigade. Exactly how the fire started, where it started and of course who is responsible is something we will get to the bottom of."

Urging witnesses to get in touch, Mr Bannister said it was possible that both offences, which he described as "terrible, terrible crimes", were linked.

The officer said neither the family nor the man who was killed were known to police.

A mosque attended by the Taufiq family issued a statement expressing shock at the deaths.

A spokesman for the Jame Mosque, about 100 yards from the family's home, said: "Four people residing at Wood Hill have tragically passed away in a house fire.

"This included Shehnila Taufiq, Zainab Taufiq and Jamal and Bilal Taufiq.

"The sons and daughters were aged between 15 and 20. The father was away in Ireland during the week working as a heart surgeon."

The family attended the mosque in Asfordby Street while Mrs Taufiq, Zainab and Bilal were also enrolled on its educational programme.

The spokesman added: "The members of our mosque, the staff and all of our colleagues are extremely shocked and are praying for them.

"We would also like to send our condolences to the father, Dr Taufiq, who, as you can imagine, would be going through a difficult time."

Mr Taufiq is a consultant neurosurgeon and has been working in Beaumont Hospital in Dublin and with private hospitals in the city, the Blackrock and Hermitage clinics.

His family lived with him for a number of years before moving to Leicester.

"The board and staff of Beaumont Hospital have learned, with shock, of the tragic loss suffered by our colleague Mr Taufiq Sattar," a spokesman said.

"We wish to express our sincere condolences to Mr Sattar and assure him that our support and thoughts are with him at this terrible time."

Colleagues at Blackrock and the Hermitage also expressed their sympathy.

"Colleagues and friends at Blackrock Clinic and Hermitage Clinic have expressed their shock at the fire in Leicester earlier today that tragically took the lives of our dear colleague's wife Shehnila and children Zainab, Bilal and Jamal," they said.

"Our thoughts and prayers are with Mr Sattar at this most difficult time."

Among friends and neighbours who paid tribute at the scene was teacher Mohammed Qasim Manjra.

Mr Manjra, who taught Jamal history at a nearby independent Islamic school, said: "He was a very sociable kid and we are very sad that he has gone.

"It's a very big shock for the community."

Leicester-based Imam Ibrahim Mogra, the assistant secretary-general of the Muslim Council of Britain, also visited the scene.

He told reporters: "Local people are devastated. It's hard to believe that such a tragedy could occur and four lives could be lost in a matter of minutes.

"I did not know them personally but from what people have told me they were a very religious family, very humble, very modest and very generous.

"The mother was a scholar herself and clearly they were a family that was into religion and education and were held in very high esteem by the local community."

Asked for his views on possible links between the fire and the murder committed in the city, Mr Mogra added: "We just have to wait for the police to carry out their investigation and I just pray that there is no link between the two incidents."

Local store-keeper Sattar Raidhan, who has lived in the area for 35 years, said: "The whole family used the shop regularly and I heard this morning that there had been a fire.

"One of the boys - the 15-year-old - came in the shop yesterday. They were a loving family and had a lot of friends.

"I believe the husband worked as a doctor in Ireland and he came home every weekend to see his family.

"I can't even imagine how this would happen to a family like that."

Labour MP Keith Vaz, who represents Leicester East, met local people near the police cordon sealing off Wood Hill.

He said: "This is a very peaceful area so this is a big shock to local people and I'm just here to show my support.

"I have spoken to the (Police and Crime) Commissioner, Sir Clive Loader, and to the Chief Constable and I think we need to let the police get on with their job.

"Only when we know the facts can we come to any conclusions as to why this has happened to an ordinary hard-working family.

"The imam has just told me they were very active in the work that they were doing locally.

"The father is a doctor and is being comforted by members of the community... a community who are clearly in grief.

"A whole family wiped out in this way, with only the father remaining, is a big shock and a real tragedy.

"If indeed people have deliberately done this, then I'm sure the police will do everything they can in order to catch them and to bring them to justice.

"We must leave the police to get all the facts together."

The force has drafted in extra officers and forensics staff to probe both crimes and increased patrols in the area.


Page 2: 17:41

The family are originally from Pakistan and have had a home in Ireland for at least 15 years.

It is understood Mr Sattar's wife was a qualified doctor but was not working.

The family, who were prominent figures in the Muslim community, were all together about a month ago when they spent the festival of Ramadan in Ireland.

The children moved to the UK with their mother about five years ago for Islamic education which is not available in Ireland but returned regularly to be with their father at the family home in the Castleknock area of the Irish capital.

Dr Ali Saleem, of the Islamic Cultural Centre in Dublin, said the family had planned to reunite in Ireland after the children finished their education.

"They were a very friendly family and a very peaceful family, and very highly educated. The children were very promising children," he said.

"He has all that taken from him now and he is left alone in his life.

"I believe he needs a strong faith to live with this tragedy. Everybody is really sad. People do not believe it. It's the worst news for him to hear in his life."

Dr Saleem spoke highly of the children, saying they had recently memorised the Koran, a rare achievement for Muslim children brought up in Ireland.

Mr Vaz later returned to the scene, having spoken with Mr Sattar.

The MP said: "He is obviously in a state of shock over what has happened and I conveyed to him the love and affection of this very close-knit community.

"They are all deeply shocked by what has happened - This is a tragedy that's wiped out all but one member of this local family."

He added: "Putting yourself in his position, you go off to work to save lives as a doctor and you arrive home and find your wife and two sons and daughter are all dead in the most horrible of circumstances. It's absolutely terrible."

Mr Vaz praised the police.

"The police have been superb in beginning the investigation, they have closed off the house and the surrounding area.

"It's now a crime scene and we want them to find out as much information as possible to establish the facts.

"The community is very, very saddened at the death of two young men, a young girl and their mother. Really, it could have been any of us standing here today.

"Any of us could have been in the same position."

Praising local people for attempting to rescue the family members, Mr Vaz continued: "People were very brave last night in trying to make sure that the family were safe.

"Five deaths in a short period of time is absolutely exceptional - this is a great tragedy."

Press Association

Read More

Editors Choice

Also in World News