Friday 9 December 2016

Becky Watts murder trial: woman accused 'suffered terrifying violence from' victim's stepbrother

Rod Minchin and Claire Hayhurst

Published 30/10/2015 | 13:54

Shauna Hoare being interviewed by police
Shauna Hoare being interviewed by police

The woman accused with her boyfriend Nathan Matthews of murdering teenager Becky Watts has told a court of suffering "terrifying" violence at his hands.

  • Go To

Shauna Hoare, 21, claimed 28-year-old Matthews strangled her during an argument and also pulled her hair, pushed her against a door and would shout and scream at her.

Hoare - who is accused alongside her boyfriend of a sexually motivated kidnap plot to murder 16-year-old Becky - described to the jury incidents during their six-year relationship.

"We were arguing over something. I sat on the end of the bed and he just lost it and grabbed me by the hair and pulled me to the other side of the bed," Hoare told Bristol Crown Court.

A candle burns besides a photograph of Becky Watts at St Ambrose Church, as her stepbrother Nathan Matthews was been charged with her murder. Photo: Matt Cardy/Getty Images
A candle burns besides a photograph of Becky Watts at St Ambrose Church, as her stepbrother Nathan Matthews was been charged with her murder. Photo: Matt Cardy/Getty Images
Court artist sketch by Elizabeth Cook of Nathan Matthews crying in the dock as Adam Vaitilingam QC (left) looks on at Bristol Crown Court, as he told the jury he did not intend to murder his stepsister Becky Watts. Photo: Elizabeth Cook/PA Wire

"I said I had stomach pains and ran to the bathroom and he followed me. (He was) very, very sorry."

Hoare also described an earlier argument with Matthews in which she told him to leave and he started stabbing himself with a fork.

"Again we were having a big argument and shouting and I'd had enough and told him to leave," she said.

"He was eating something and had a fork in his hand and he jumped on me - not hurting me - and started stabbing himself in the chest and was scrapping the fork down his face."

Rebecca Watts,16, known as Becky
Rebecca Watts,16, known as Becky
Rebecca Watts Credit: Avon and Somerset Police/PA Wire

Asked by Andrew Langdon QC, defending, her reaction to that, Hoare replied: "Terrifying."

Describing an incident when he strangled her, Hoare said: "During another row he almost ran at me and put his hands round my neck and strangled me.

Asked how she felt, Hoare replied: "Horrible, I couldn't breathe, I felt panic, I was scared.

"He always apologised but not always right away... It would take a while. He would explain that it was the way I was annoying him.

Undated handout photo issued by Avon & Somerset Police of scene photographs released in the Becky Watts murder trial, of the bathroom at 14 Cotton Mill Lane, Barton Hill, the home of her stepbrother Nathan Matthews, 28, and his girlfriend Shauna Hoare, 21, where it is alleged that the teenagers body was driven to on the night of her alleged murder and later dismembered in the bathroom. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Issue date: Tuesday October 13, 2015. See PA story COURTS Missing. Photo credit should read: Avon & Somerset Police/PA Wire
NOTE TO EDITORS: This handout photo may only be used in for editorial reporting purposes for the contemporaneous illustration of events, things or the people in the image or facts mentioned in the caption. Reuse of the picture may require further permission from the copyright holder.
Undated handout photo issued by Avon & Somerset Police of scene photographs released in the Becky Watts murder trial, of the bathroom at 14 Cotton Mill Lane, Barton Hill, the home of her stepbrother Nathan Matthews, 28, and his girlfriend Shauna Hoare, 21, where it is alleged that the teenagers body was driven to on the night of her alleged murder and later dismembered in the bathroom. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Issue date: Tuesday October 13, 2015. See PA story COURTS Missing. Photo credit should read: Avon & Somerset Police/PA Wire NOTE TO EDITORS: This handout photo may only be used in for editorial reporting purposes for the contemporaneous illustration of events, things or the people in the image or facts mentioned in the caption. Reuse of the picture may require further permission from the copyright holder.
Undated handout photo issued by Avon & Somerset Police of scene photographs released in the Becky Watts murder trial, of her bedroom at 18 Crown Hill, St George, Bristol, where she was allegedly murdered by her stepbrother Nathan Matthews, 28, and his girlfriend Shauna Hoare, 21. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Issue date: Tuesday October 13, 2015. It is claimed Matthews and Hoare targeted Becky in a sexually motivated kidnap plot on February 19 this year, which culminated in her death. Her body was put in the boot of their Vauxhall Zafira before being driven on the night of the alleged murder to their home at 14 Cotton Mill Lane, Barton Hill and later dismembered in the bathroom. See PA story COURTS Missing. Photo credit should read: Avon & Somerset Police/PA Wire NOTE TO EDITORS: This handout photo may only be used in for editorial reporting purposes for the contemporaneous illustration of events, things or the people in the image or facts mentioned in the caption. Reuse of the picture may require further permission from the copyright holder.
Undated handout photo issued by Avon & Somerset Police of scene photographs released in the Becky Watts murder trial, of her bedroom at 18 Crown Hill, St George, Bristol, where she was allegedly murdered by her stepbrother Nathan Matthews, 28, and his girlfriend Shauna Hoare, 21. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Issue date: Tuesday October 13, 2015. It is claimed Matthews and Hoare targeted Becky in a sexually motivated kidnap plot on February 19 this year, which culminated in her death. Her body was put in the boot of their Vauxhall Zafira before being driven on the night of the alleged murder to their home at 14 Cotton Mill Lane, Barton Hill and later dismembered in the bathroom. See PA story COURTS Missing. Photo credit should read: Avon & Somerset Police/PA Wire NOTE TO EDITORS: This handout photo may only be used in for editorial reporting purposes for the contemporaneous illustration of events, things or the people in the image or facts mentioned in the caption. Reuse of the picture may require further permission from the copyright holder.

"We didn't go out for a day or two until the red mark around my neck was gone."

Hoare also told the court that she knew if Matthews was going to get violent because the tone of his voice changed.

"He had a tone of voice, you kind of get to know it from the violence," she said.

"He would be shouting, clench his fists and would step forward and throw something at you but he wouldn't actually hit me.

"(I felt) scared because I didn't know what he was going to do. I've seen him argue with other people but not in the way that I have described."

Matthews, of Hazelbury Drive, Warmley, South Gloucestershire, denies murder and conspiracy to kidnap.

He admits killing Becky, perverting the course of justice, preventing the burial of a corpse and possessing a prohibited weapon.

Hoare, of Cotton Mill Lane, Bristol, denies murder, conspiracy to kidnap, perverting the course of justice, preventing burial of a corpse and possessing a prohibited weapon.

The residents of the Barton Court property, Karl Demetrius, 30, and his partner Jaydene Parsons, 23, admit assisting an offender.

Donovan Demetrius - Karl's twin brother - of Marsh Lane, Bristol, and James Ireland, 23, of Richmond Villas, Avonmouth - a work colleague of Karl's - deny the charge.

Hoare also described to the court an incident in which Matthews lost his temper at a GP surgery and punched a wall - breaking his fingers.

"Nathan wanted help with his mental health. He was getting annoyed because he couldn't get his words out. He was afraid the doctor would tell social services.

"Then he just exploded, I heard the bang and apologised to the doctor."

Hoare also said that Matthews could be "very funny" and during their six-year relationship they had good times and bad times, which depended on his mood.

But she told the jury that he would control what food she ate and at times she would have to "beg", Hoare insisted.

"The majority of the time I would ask for something and he would say no so I would continue to ask - almost begging in a sense," she said.

"It could be a sandwich, some sort of pastry or a drink. Some of the time he would say it had too much fat and I needed to lose weight."

Mr Langdon asked his client about evidence heard during the trial of takeaways being ordered, such as pizza.

"If he wanted something he was a lot more likely to say yes," Hoare explained.

The court heard that she started smoking at 13 and Matthews did not like her habit and she would have to pay him.

"I would pay him £5 a week for him to allow me to have one pack of cigarettes," she said.

"At the beginning I would buy them but as time went on Nathan would buy them or I would take money out of the bank card and buy cigarettes.

"I would hide the cigarettes. Towards the end of the relationship I would take cigarettes to the shop and smoke and I would always have moisturiser for my hands, perfume and chewing gum in my bag to disguise the smell.

"If he was in a good mood and I was quite persistent he would allow me to smoke. He might have just woken up and just generally been in a good mood.

The jury heard Hoare say that she wanted to leave Matthews two years ago but could not, telling the court: "I had nowhere else to go, I had no one else and he would find out and it would go back to normal.

"If he found me he would be very angry."

Mr Langdon asked Hoare about a threesome she and Matthews had with a female friend, asking her who was "into it" more.

Hoare replied: "Nathan."

She also said she had experimented sexually with another girl when she was younger.

She said: "I was 13 or 14, it was another girl and it lasted a week - just kissing and on-top-of-clothes fondling.

"I exaggerated a lot of it to make myself seem more exciting and appealing to him."

The court also heard details of a prepared statement Hoare gave police in May this year about messages recovered from her phone discussing kidnapping teenage girls.

In one message, Hoare wrote: "Just went into Costcutter and saw a pretty petite girl. Almost knocked her out to bring home lol xoxo"

A reply 20 seconds later from Matthews read: "Don't you 'almost' me ... Now DO IT bitch!! xxxxx"

Hoare then said: "lmfao yeah I'll just go back in time to when I saw her then time travel her to our attic lol xoxo"

Hoare described the "panic" when police confronted her with the evidence and agreed she lied to the officers, blaming Matthews.

Asked why she lied, Hoare replied: "I knew what Nathan had been charged with and knew what actually happened and I knew how bad it looked.

"I regret it massively because, one, I should not have lied and, second, because of the way it looks and I should have told the truth in the first place."

Hoare also said if she was out alone she would dream up messages to send to Matthews to get him in a good mood when she returned.

"Sometimes I would make things up to get him in a good mood," she added.

She also told the court that she did not like the way Matthews cluttered up their Cotton Mill Lane home with his hoarding and he would not let her cut her hair short because she would look like a "lesbian".

Hoare said she was aware Matthews watched pornography but she did not watch it with him.

Asked about her boyfriend's attitude to teenage girls, Hoare said: "Occasionally he would make inappropriate comments, saying how he would like to have sex with them.

"He would generally say: 'I would give them a go'."

The court heard Hoare describe her boyfriend's paranoia with him not wanting anyone to know he was living with her.

"He was extremely paranoid. He wouldn't let me go out on my own. He would always make sure every door - every bolt - was locked," she said.

Press Association

Read More

Promoted articles

Editors Choice

Also in World News