Thursday 29 September 2016

They're all heroes but here's how the Ireland players rated in the 1-0 win over Germany

John Brennan

Published 08/10/2015 | 21:58

Shane Long got the all-important goal but every Irish player was a warrior tonight in the 1-0 win over Germany. Here's how they rated.

  • Go To

Shay Given- Struggled to direct his kick-outs to Irish players. Maybe that knee was bothering him all the time. 6

Cyrus Christie- Struggled at times as the opposition targeted his inexperience but he stood tall. Seamus Coleman will be welcomed back for Sunday. 7

John O'Shea- The Sunderland man was solid all through, just as he has been in every game of the campaign so far. 8

Richard Keogh- A few nervy clearances from the centre-half were understandable as Keogh was pitched into this massive match. 6

Stephen Ward- A shock choice in the Irish defence, and Germany went after the Burnley left-back for the whole game, but he stood firm. 7

James McCarthy- Everton and Ireland's midfielder put himself about a bit as he sought to halt Germany's advances.7

Jeff Hendrick- Beginning to blossom as an international footballer, Hendrick is certainly a building block for the future. 7

Robbie Brady- Worked hard for the whole game up and down the wing. Sacrificed a bit going forward for his defensive duties. 8

Wes Hoolahan- The one Irish player who, for touch and technique, would have been at home on the German team. 9

8 October 2015; Shane Long, Republic of Ireland, celebrates after scoring his side's opening goal. UEFA EURO 2016 Championship Qualifier, Group D, Republic of Ireland v Germany. Aviva Stadium, Lansdowne Road, Dublin. Picture credit: David Maher / SPORTSFILE
8 October 2015; Shane Long, Republic of Ireland, celebrates after scoring his side's opening goal. UEFA EURO 2016 Championship Qualifier, Group D, Republic of Ireland v Germany. Aviva Stadium, Lansdowne Road, Dublin. Picture credit: David Maher / SPORTSFILE
Shane Long, Republic of Ireland, celebrates after scoring his side's opening goal. UEFA EURO 2016 Championship Qualifier, Group D, Republic of Ireland v Germany. Aviva Stadium, Lansdowne Road, Dublin. Picture credit: David Maher / SPORTSFILE
Shane Long, Republic of Ireland, shoots past Germany goalkeeper Manuel Neuer to score his side's first goal despite the attempts of J?r?me Boateng. UEFA EURO 2016 Championship Qualifier, Group D, Republic of Ireland v Germany. Aviva Stadium, Lansdowne Road, Dublin. Picture credit: David Maher / SPORTSFILE
Shane Long, Republic of Ireland, shoots to score his side's first goal despite the attempts of J?r?me Boateng, Germany. UEFA EURO 2016 Championship Qualifier, Group D, Republic of Ireland v Germany. Aviva Stadium, Lansdowne Road, Dublin. Picture credit: Matt Browne / SPORTSFILE
Germany's Jerome Boateng and Republic of Ireland's Jonathan Walters (right) battle for the ball during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin.
Germany's Jerome Boateng and Republic of Ireland's Jeff Hendrick (right) battle for the ball during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Republic of Ireland's Wes Hoolahan during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Germany's Jonas Hector and Republic of Ireland's James McCarthy (right) battle for the ball during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Mario Gotze before going off injured Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Mario Gotze before going off injured Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland manager Martin O'Neill Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland manager Martin O'Neill Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland manager Martin O'Neill Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Germany's Bastian Schweinsteiger (centre) before the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Shay Given is stretchered off for Darren Randolph after sustaining an injury as manager Martin O'Neill looks on Reuters / Phil Noble Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Republic of Ireland assistant manager Roy Keane (left) and manager Martin O'Neill before the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Republic of Ireland assistant manager Roy Keane during the warm-up before the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Shay Given is stretchered off after sustaining an injury as manager Martin O'Neill looks on Reuters / Phil Noble Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Republic of Ireland's Wes Hoolahan and Germany's Jerome Boateng (left) battle for the ball during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Germany manager Joachim Low on the touchline during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Jonathan Walters in action with Germany's Matthias Ginter Reuters / Phil Noble Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Republic of Ireland's Daryl Murphy and Germany's Jerome Boateng (right) battle for the ball during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's James McCarthy Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Ilkay Gundogan Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Jonathan Walters in action with Germany's Matthias Ginter Reuters / Phil Noble Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Ilkay Gundogan Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's James McCarthy Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Shay Given is stretchered off after sustaining an injury Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Shay Given is stretchered off after sustaining an injury Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Shay Given is stretchered off after sustaining an injury Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Jerome Boateng in action with Republic of Ireland's Jonathan Walters Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Mario Gotze in action with Republic of Ireland's James McCarthy Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Republic of Ireland's Stephen Ward Reuters / Phil Noble Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Manuel Neuer Reuters / Phil Noble Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.
Republic of Ireland's Jonathan Walters (left) goes down under a challenge from Germany's Mats Hummels during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Republic of Ireland's Wes Hoolahan (right) in action with Germany's Mesut Ozil and Ilkay Gundogan (left) during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Republic of Ireland's Robert Brady and Germany's Jerome Boateng (left) battle for the ball during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Republic of Ireland's Robert Brady in action during the UEFA European Championship Qualifying match at the Aviva Stadium, Dublin. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday October 8, 2015. See PA story SOCCER Republic. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire.
Football - Republic of Ireland v Germany - UEFA Euro 2016 Qualifying Group D - Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Republic of Ireland - 8/10/15 Germany's Thomas Muller in action with Republic of Ireland's Stephen Ward Action Images via Reuters / Andrew Couldridge Livepic EDITORIAL USE ONLY.

Daryl Murphy- Asked to move between a lone attacker and playing wide in midfield and did the job as best he could. 7

Jon Walters- Another immense shift from the Stoke player who worked hard all night for little reward in the way of a decent pass. 8

Subs

Darren Randolph- Two great saves when pressed into service in the second half 7

Shane Long- A goal that everyone will remember forever. What a finish past the best goalkeeper in the world. 8

Read all of our content on the game here: http://www.independent.ie/sport/

GERMANY

Manuel Neuer-  Not even the brilliant Neuer could keep out keep out shane Long's great finish. 7

Matthias Ginter- Tried to get forward from full-back, but there was not a lot of end product. 6

Mats Hummels- Had a quiet night as Ireland rarely attacked, but was beaten by Long's pace for the goal. 6

Jerome Boateng- Marked absent when needed at the heart of Germany's defence. One piledriver of a shot in the second half. 6

Jonas Hector- Like Ginter on the other side, the German full-back found the Irish defence unyielding. 6

Marco Reus- There were times when he threatened to win the game for Germany on his own. 8

Mezut Ozil- A stride offside for one goal and missed a great chance for another. 6

Toni Kroos- Like Reus, Kroos could have carved Ireland apart - somehow he never did. 7

Ilkay Gundogan- The least impressive of the German midfield on the night. 5

Thomas Muller- How did this brilliant player miss that second half chance from 12 yards. 7

Mario Gotze- Had to go off injured in the first half, having threatened Ireland. 6

 

Subs- Andre Schurrle- He too missed a great opportunity for the goal Germany needed. 7

Kevin Volland- Made no impact when he came on in the second half.

Online Editors

Read More

Promoted articles

Editor's Choice

Also in Sport