England must give Carroll a chance -- Barton
Published 09/11/2010 | 05:00
A character reference from Joey Barton is perhaps not what Andy Carroll needs right now as the Newcastle United striker presses his claims for inclusion in Fabio Capello's England squad to face France next week.
Were the decision to be made on footballing criteria alone, Carroll would almost certainly be heading for an England debut in next Wednesday's Wembley friendly.
His performance and goal in Sunday's 1-0 win at Arsenal suggested he could become the player Capello so desperately craves, someone with the ability and character to put in the work and lead the line, but who also possesses the talent to weigh in with his fair share of goals. With Darren Bent, Bobby Zamora and Jermain Defoe injured, and Wayne Rooney doubtful, the time has come for Carroll (21) to be given a chance.
Picking him, however, will be fraught with problems. The FA has concerns, as Carroll faces the threat of jail over an impending court case, and he has so far shown no sign he is willing to curb his wilder moments of excess.
Enter Joey Barton, Carroll's Newcastle team-mate, who served 77 days in jail for common assault and affray in 2008. Speaking after Newcastle's victory at the Emirates, Barton accused Capello and his predecessors as England manager of picking players based on their "goody two-shoes" reputations rather than their form and fitness.
"If you want to win football matches then sometimes you need players who don't always toe the line," Barton said. "Every other national team picks players because they're best in their position. The frustrating thing for me is we pick the good guys, the guys who won't cause any problems.
"Hopefully England will stop worrying about what the sponsors are going to say and if 'goody two-shoes' is the right image for Team England. They need to start picking players to win football matches."
Barton's comments highlight the dilemma facing Capello, and he has a point. It is doubtful that such a controversial figure as Diego Maradona would have become one of the all-time greats had he been born in Birmingham instead of Buenos Aires.
The easiest thing would be if Carroll were to mend his ways, and Barton has shown in the past two years it is possible to change. "What I've found in later life is that you become more mature and that was a way of getting the best out of myself," Barton said.
Barton is confident the same will be true of Carroll. "He's a great kid, a wayward rogue like I was."
Carroll played down the England talk, and was unaware that Capello had been at the Emirates to see him score. "I didn't know that. I've just got to see what happens," he said. (© Independent News Service)