Sunday, May 27 2012

Mostly Sunny Dublin Hi 19 °C | Lo 11°C

Letters

Censoring carried out on our behalf

Wednesday February 13 2008

It is perhaps an understatement to say that some of the arguments put forward by Kevin Myers in his article 'Banishing Ghosts of a Rising' (Irish Independent, February 7), whereby he selects specific parts of Irish life since independence and draws comparisons with life in Ireland under British rule to show how dysfunctional we are and unfit to govern ourselves, are extraordinary.

"The insane political and economic priorities created by revolutionary gun culture," referred to by Mr Myers, which apparently plunged us down the pecking order in wealth creation, totally ignores, as usual, the unjustified violence of colonisation inflicted on this country, yet condemns, as usual, in the clearest manner possible, the justified violence of resistance to such colonisation.

By any standards, Mr Myers' critique of Irish life since independence, focusing specifically on the Censorship Board as he did, is unwarranted, as most, if not all, fledgling states in finding their feet, so to speak, evolve in their own time until their standards are identified and reflected in legislation.

"The open air lunatic asylum," which Mr Myers disparagingly refers to Ireland as, was not by any means unique in its censorship laws.

Take for example Britain, where Mr Myers is from.

Chris Moore's 'The Kincora Scandal' was banned for alleging British cover-up over Satanic abuse.

'Rights of Man' (Thomas Paine) was also to fall victim to the censors, as was Peter Wright's' 'Spycatcher' in 1987.

Even George Orwell fell victim to censorship.

'Star Trek -- The Next Generation' suffered the same fate when an episode which referred to the conflict in Northern Ireland was withdrawn.

In 1985, the British government intervened to prevent a 'Real Lives' documentary on BBC, 'At the Edge of the Union', being aired. This action led to a strike by the NUJ to defend the independence of the BBC.

From 1988 to 1994, the voices of Irish republicans were banned on UK television and radio, with actors re-voicing the words.

In 1988, Channel 4 dropped plans to invite an elected member of parliament, Gerry Adams, to appear on the night-time talk show 'After Dark', following an appeal from the British prime minister.

I think we can assume that no society or country holds copyrights on censorship, nor should we be disproportionately judgmental of others.

What Mr Myers seems not to grasp is that the banning of books or other items and the subsequent unbanning of them was carried out by an organ of the Irish Government, acting on behalf of the Irish people.

We made our mistakes and we rectified them ourselves without reference to a foreign state. This is the legacy of 1916. This is our inheritance.

TOM COOPER

DELAFORD LAWN, DUBLIN 16

 
 

Video Highlights

(video)

Oldest woman defeats Everest again

Watanabe reached the summit from the Tibetan side on 19 May, at the age of 73 years and 180 days. That day, more than 200 climbers were aiming for the summit on the busier southern route in Nepal. Four died, apparently from altitude sickness and exhaustion, on one of the deadliest days on the mountain.

(video)

Irish players prepare to pack bags for Euro 2012

Republic of Ireland stars preparing to pack their backs for Euro 2012 training base have been making the most of the summer sunshine in north county Dublin. There is a small matter of their Euro 2012 farewell friendly against Bosnia first. Shane

(video)

Gazza get his tongue out again

Gazza, capped 57 times, last appeared in an England shirt against Belgium in 1998 and now he wears the Three Lions once more as England gears up for Europe?s biggest football tournament

View more



Highlights

Independentwoman.ie

Independent Woman

A fresh, fun site featuring celeb gossip, fashion, beauty, love & sex, and health & fitness.

Findajob.ie

Job search

Search for jobs by keyword, category, or location.

College

Third Level College

Diploma, Degree, Postgraduate and Professional Courses

Yourlocal.ie

Directory

Wherever you are... Find what you're looking for on Yourlocal.ie.

GrabOne

GrabOne

Daily Deals: Find the best things to do, see and eat in Ireland