Motoring

Wednesday 30 July 2014

Different cars strike chord with different voters

Eddie Cunningham Motoring Editor

Published 28/11/2012|05:00

  • Share

BMW 3-series a controversial choice

  • Share
  • Go To

It is a privilege to be involved in motoring journalism. You, the reader, (potential buyer) make it such with your feedback and comments (not always favourable).

So I need to be upfront with you. I do not have a vote in the Continental Irish Car of the Year because I do not belong to the Irish Motor Writers' Association (IMWA).

My great, old, now sadly deceased Editor Vinny Doyle, told me I should aim to be independent and not let anything else really matter. I have tried. So have members of the IMWA, I have no doubt, some of whom I would regard as friends and many of whom I would respect as thorough professionals.

Which gives me the privilege to disagree with them – and they with me.

As you can see from the accompanying piece (below), the BMW 3-series won the Car of the Year award last week. It is a great car and I loved it when I drove it.

Whether an executive motor is a Car of the Year in a country that is broke is a moot point. I applaud it. Well done. The mould has been broken.

If I had a vote, I would have gone for the Ford B-MAX, which I think is innovative, family-oriented and well priced. I feel it should have at least been in the shakeup.

Maybe it was too late for inclusion, I don't know. But the Honda Civic was in plenty of time and wasn't mentioned. And so was the Volkswagen up! city car.

By coincidence, I had the 5dr version for a couple of days last week and was, again, mightily impressed with it. I would have had it in the shakeup.

Just so long as you know, dear reader, that I am prepared to risk the wrath of friends to comment on something that is on the one hand none of my business – I am not a member – but on the other is very much your business because an award of this stature carries clout. And that makes it my business.

I don't expect headlines for Eddie Cunningham's car of the year. But at least you know where I stand. You, and I, are entitled to that.

Indo Motoring

Read More

Classifieds

CarsIreland

Independent Shopping.ie

Meet, chat and connect with
singles in your area

Independent Shopping.ie

Meet Singles Now

Findajob

Apps

Now available on

Editors Choice



Also in Life