Wednesday 7 December 2016

Voting No to same-sex marriage is not homophobic, say bishops

Greg Harkin

Published 04/05/2015 | 02:30

Archbishop Eamon Martin
Archbishop Eamon Martin
Bishop Philip Boyce

The Catholic Church stepped up its campaign for a 'No' vote in the marriage equality referendum, with its leading bishops issuing pastoral letters to their dioceses amid claims 'No' campaigners were being branded homophobic.

  • Go To

The leader of Ireland's four million Catholics, Archbishop Eamon Martin, kicked off a series of statements opposing a 'Yes' vote and was followed yesterday by senior bishops around the country.

"We have got ourselves into the situation that many people won't even raise these issues in their families and workplaces for fear of being ridiculed or condemned as homophobic," said Dr Martin.

He said it is a "fact of nature" that same-sex unions are "fundamentally and objectively different" from the sexual union of a woman and a man, which is "naturally open to life".

He said the church "cannot support an amendment to the Constitution which redefines marriage and effectively places the union of two men, or two women, on a par with the marriage relationship between a husband and wife."

Pastoral letters from eight senior bishops were also read out by priests at parish Masses around the country yesterday.

Bishop of Raphoe Philip Boyce insisted: "Equality and human rights should be afforded to everyone, but it should be done without sacrificing the institution of marriage and the family.

"The church respects an equality that recognises difference, not an equality that destroys all difference.

"To recognise the difference in the way we are made is not discrimination and it does not undermine equality."

Reflecting the view of his fellow bishops, Dr Boyce said the Church accepts people "with homosexual tendencies" with respect and compassion but their legal rights were already protected in civil partnerships.

He said a 'Yes' vote on May 22 would have "serious implications" for children.

"Every child, no matter what sexual orientation he or she may have, has the human right to a father and a mother," said Dr Boyce.

"We should not vote to legalise intentionally a situation where a child would be fatherless or motherless, not able to say 'dad' and 'mammy' to two parents."

The Bishop of Meath Michael Smith said there hadn't been a meaningful debate in Dáil Eireann.

"I do not think that there is anything offensive in believing, as we have always done, that marriage is a permanent union between a man and a woman," said Bishop Smith.

"The search for equality in our society will not be advanced by undermining the very cornerstone on which a just and stable society is built."

However, the Faith in Marriage Equality group called on the church to "respect the freedom of conscience" of those Catholics voting 'Yes'.

Irish Independent

Read More

Promoted articles

Editors Choice

Also in this section