European watchdog finds no link between HPV vaccine and abnormal symptoms
Published 05/11/2015 | 15:46
A European watchdog has found no causal link between the anti-cervical cancer HPV vaccine, which is given to millions of teenage girls including Ireland, and abnormal symptoms such as chronic pain and seizures.
The findings of the investigation arm of the European Medicines Agency followed reports of abnormal symptoms suffered by girls after getting the HPV vaccine.
At least 110 parents in Ireland have reported their daughters suffered severe effects after getting the vaccine with several unable to attend school as a result.
The European review looked at two conditions, complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) and postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) in young women given the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines.
These vaccines are given to protect them from cervical cancer and other HPV-related cancers and pre-cancerous conditions.
The review concluded that the evidence does not support a causal link between the vaccines (Cervarix, Gardasil/Silgard and Gardasil-9) and development of CRPS or POTS.
Therefore there is no reason to change the way the vaccines are used or amend the current product information.
CRPS is a chronic pain syndrome affecting a limb, while POTS is a condition where the heart rate increases abnormally on sitting or standing up, together with symptoms such as dizziness, fainting and weakness, as well as headache, aches and pains, nausea and fatigue.
In some patients they can severely affect the quality of life. The syndromes are recognised to occur in the general population, including adolescents, regardless of vaccination.
PRAC thoroughly reviewed the published research, data from clinical trials and reports of suspected side effects from patients and healthcare professionals, as well as data supplied by member states including Ireland.
It also consulted a group of leading experts in the field, and took into account detailed information received from a number of patient groups that also highlighted the impact these syndromes can have on patients and families.
Symptoms of CRPS and POTS may overlap with other conditions, making diagnosis difficult in both the general population and vaccinated individuals.
However, available estimates suggest that in the general population around 150 girls and young women per million aged 10 to 19 years may develop CRPS each year, and at least 150 girls and young women per million may develop POTS each year.
The review found no evidence that the overall rates of these syndromes in vaccinated girls were different from expected rates in these age groups, even taking into account possible underreporting.
The PRAC noted that some symptoms of CRPS and POTS may overlap with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS, also known as myalgic encephalomyelitis or ME).
Many of the reports considered in the review have features of CFS and some patients had diagnoses of both POTS and CFS. Results of a large published study that showed no link between HPV vaccine and CFS were therefore particularly relevant.
The PRAC concluded that the available evidence does not support that CRPS and POTS are caused by HPV vaccines. Therefore there is no reason to change the way the vaccines are used or amend the current product information.
The review recognised that more than 80 million girls and women worldwide have now received these vaccines, and in some European countries they have been given to 90pc of the age group recommended for vaccination. Use of these vaccines is expected to prevent many cases of cervical cancer (cancer of the neck of the womb, which is responsible for tens of thousands of deaths in Europe each year) and various other cancers and conditions caused by HPV.
The benefits of HPV vaccines therefore continue to outweigh their risks. The safety of these vaccines, as with all medicines, will continue to be carefully monitored.
The PRAC’s recommendations will now be passed to the Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) for adoption of the Agency’s final position. The evidence supporting the PRAC review will be published in an assessment report following the CHMP opinion.
The findings have been met with disappointment by the group R.E.G.R.E.T which has over 110 families which has been campaigning for recognition of the condition.
Pierce Cullen from Wexford whose granddaughter Ava has been affected said families are coming up against obstacles in getting a diagnosis,
“We want medical assistance and we are not anti-vaccine. We need help.We are just meeting bureaucrats who are sending us around in circles.
“All we are looking is for kids to be taken care of.”